Just reviewing this thread and I'm responding to Coalsmoke's question about memorable pipe shops. First-let me say that back then, all pipe shops were good or better. There was no Internet, and the only way that you could get pipes, tobacco use and other supplies was by visiting the shop, or mailing those that had mail order systems in place. I made it a point to visit the pipe shop in any town I happened to be visiting, and always bought something – – the pipe, some tobacco, or other supplies. That said, here are some of my most notable brick-and-mortar places:
1. Fred Diebel- in Kansas Cit's upscale Country Club Plaza. This was the first pipe shop I ever visited, back in early 1961. It was a grand and glorious place, filled to the brim with exquisite pipes and equally exquisite tobaccos. Fred was patient and taught me a good deal about what I learned about pipe smoking in those early days. The shop still exists, but it bears only a slight resemblance to what it was.
2. David P. Ehrlich and Leavitt and Peirce- mainstays of the Boston pipe scene. They had it all, and generations of Harvard students and other proper Bostonians were regulars. I smoked their flagship blend, DPE for quite a few years. Ehrlichs is closed, and L&P, while still there in their original Harvard Square location, is a pale shadow of its former self. The staff know little or nothing about pipe smoking, and are simply sale clerks who will take your purchase and ring it up for you. You can still buy DPE, but the formula has changed somewhat, even though it still tastes pretty close to the original blend. They still sell Cake Box, and it's still a great blend. Judge's Mixture is also a tobacco worth noting.
3. Smoker's Haven in Columbus, Ohio. Again, a premier shop and Premal has done superlative work in keeping it going. I had a small tin of their flagship Our Best Blend (good old Balkan Sobranie packed under their label,) which I opened and shared with Premal a couple of years ago. The tin had absolutely no rust, inside or out, and the tobacco was amazing. I still have a large tin of OBB which I'm holding on to, until a heavenly voice tells me to open it.
4. Iwan Ries-- great then and now-a not to be missed experience.
5. Carousel- Cincinnati's best. They've changed a bit, but still worth a visit. After I handed in my dissertation, I worked there for a few months until graduation, fulfilling a childhood dream. It was a great experience, one I still look back on with some fondness.
6. Edward's - in various locations. They had great pipes and tobaccos, and some of the blends are still available.
There are still a few brick-and-mortar places open, and are all worth a visit.