10 Best Pipe Tobaccos... According to Me (YMMV)

[prairiedruid]

3 Oaks Syrian
PS LNF
PS LBF
Black Frigate
PS Proper English
Christmas Cheer
Crooner
PS Cube Cut
Triple Play
Motzek Strang

 

[Grangerous]

Soy demasiado novato para fumar esa calidad de tabaco ...

Nope. I give him less than 5 years.....

Here’s what happens when you hit that wall, Prof B

1.) G
2.) R
3.) A
4.) N
5.) G
6.) E
7.)R
8.) C
9.) A
10.) N

 

[sablebrush52]

Motzek Strang
Escudo - (A & C Petersen or earlier, not the current STG shit)
McClelland 40th, Christmas Cheer, McCranie's Red Ribbon and Red flake
FVP, FVF
St James Flake
Dunbar
GP-11
HU 5th Anniversary
George Huber Virginia Golden Flake
Haddo's Delight
Capstan Blue
GL Pease Renaissance

and a few dozen more that I enjoy.

One's perceptions change with exploration. Some of the above will be on my list until I give up the pipe or go into the ground. Others will change.

 

[canucklehead]

I can tell you what they are today, but it will probably be different tomorrow.
D&R Windsail
D&R Ryback
SG Squadron Leader
Dunhill Early Morning Pipe
Dunhill Deluxe Navy Rolls
Presbyterian
GH Brown Flake Unscented
C&D Sea Dog
C&D Izmir Turkish
C&D Dark Burley

 

[tschiraldi]

1. F&T Vintage
2. PS Luxury Twist Flake
3.F&T Cut Blended Plug
4. F&T Cut Virginia Plug
5. F&T Blackjack
6. Reiner's Long Golden Flake
7. Esoterica Stonehaven
8. Esoterica Dunbar
9. C&D Crooner
10. Dunhill Dark Flake

 

[peregrinus]

Current top five:

SG St. James Flake
SG Full Virginia Flake
Salty Dogs
HU Director’s Cut
Christmas Cheer

 

[hoosierpipeguy]

Bub? Got it there boss, my humblest of apologies, I’ll go hide my head in shame.

My preference would be for this noobie to show senior members like ashdigger a bit of respect.

 

[UncleRasta]

Black Frigate
Solani Silver Flake
Yenidje Highlander
Angler's Dream
Watch City Slices
Christmas Cheer
Salty Dogs
Devil's Holiday
Deep Hollow
Three Year Matured Virginia

Wow. I haven't gotten around to any of these, and Solani Silver Flake is the only one currently on my to-do list.

 

[UncleRasta]

From my limited perspective of only 18 months in the game, and in no particular order:
HH Balkan Blend
Sutliff 507 Slices
Quiet Nights
Amphora Burley
HH Burley
Plum Pudding
Solani 633 Flake
PS Luxury Navy Flake
HH Pure Virginia
HH Latakia Flake.

I am already second guessing this list.

 

[gamzultovah]

My preference would be for this noobie to show senior members like ashdigger a bit of respect.

Hear, hear...

 

[seanv]

Right now I am stuck on only 2 blends

Old Joe Krantz Blue Label
Pegasus

 

[didimauw]

1. C
2. A
3. R
4. T
5. E
6. R
7. H
8. A
9. L
10. L

 

[sandollars]

1. Solani 656
2. Esoterica Stonehaven
3. Tabac Manil Pure Semois (any of the 3 cuts)
4. WC Deluxe Crumb Cut
5. G&H Happy Brown Bogie
6. LJP 150th Anniversary
7. G&H Dark Plug
8. LJP Thanksgiving Day
9. Balkan Supreme
10. HH Old Dark Fired

This is my current favorites list which is significantly different from the last time I replied to one of these top favorites threads and will surely change again in the future.

The only ones that are permanently etched on my top 10 list are:

Solani 656
Esoterica Stonehaven
Tabac Manil Pure Semois (any cut, makes no difference to me...)

 

[Winterreise]

St Bruno
1792
Whiteknight
G&H Balkan Mixture
St James Flake
Plum Pudding SR
Irish Flake
Stonehenge
Ennerdale
Solani Aged Burley Flake

 

[python]

1. C
2. A
3. R
4. T
5. E
6. R
7. H
8. A
9. L
10. L

What happened to Briar Fox?

 

[sandollars]

G. L. Pease Spark Plug-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East Flake-​

C&D Pirate Kake-​

GL Pease: Odyssey-​

Cornell & Diehl: Byzantium-​

Cornell & Diehl: Mountain Camp-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East bulk-​

G. L. Pease: Meridian-​

Cornell & Diehl: Yorktown-​

Cornell & Diehl: Blockade Runner-​

I am trying to figure out why it disturbs me a little that I very much like every single blend on Embers list.....

 

[UncleRasta]

I am trying to figure out why it disturbs me a little that I very much like every single blend on Embers list.....

Well. I've never seen you both in the same (chat?)room at the same time...

 

[sandollars]

We have CHAT ROOMS?

 

[foursidedtriangle]

G. L. Pease Spark Plug-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East Flake-​

C&D Pirate Kake-​

GL Pease: Odyssey-​

Cornell & Diehl: Byzantium-​

Cornell & Diehl: Mountain Camp-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East bulk-​

G. L. Pease: Meridian-​

Cornell & Diehl: Yorktown-​

Cornell & Diehl: Blockade Runner-​

You have amazing taste. GLP Meridian may be my favourite and Star of the East bulk is can’t miss bulk offering.

 

[judcole]

Perhaps you could say this is a collective review?

A "review" tells the reader something about the tobacco (s) discussed.