10 Best Pipe Tobaccos... According to Me (YMMV)

[Professor B]

1. Lane RLP-6

2. Bell's Three Nuns (Mac Baren version)

3. Savinelli Cavendish

4. Lane 1Q

5. Mac Baren Vanilla Creme

6. Peterson Irish Whiskey

7. Ashton Consummate Gentleman

8. Mac Baren Mixture "Scottish Blend"

9. Peterson Royal Yacht Mixture

10. Carter Hall

 

[judcole]

I don't see any reviews here. Perhaps this should be moved to the General Pipe Smoking Discussion section.
5'll get you 10 that this list will not be the same in five years.

 

[musicman]

Well, we obviously have different tastes, but I can't argue with your list. Mine would be (in no particular order):
Sam Gawith St. James Flake
Match Victoria
C and D Pegasus
WC Rouxgaroux
Gl Pease Cairo
C and D Black Frigate
Gawith Bosun Cut Plug
Rattray's Marlin Flake
Esoterica Dunbar
WC Simply Red

 

[JOHN72]

No veo ninguna crítica aquí. Quizás esto debería trasladarse a la sección Discusión general sobre fumar en pipa.
5 te daré 10 que esta lista no será la misma en cinco años.

Soy demasiado novato para fumar esa calidad de tabaco ...

 

[Captain Granger]

Soy demasiado novato para fumar esa calidad de tabaco ...

I cry "foul," sir. No serious pipe smoker would laugh at another's preferences, especially when he had the courage to share them publicly.

 

[Professor B]

I don't see any reviews here. Perhaps this should be moved to the General Pipe Smoking Discussion section.
5'll get you 10 that this list will not be the same in five years.

Perhaps you could say this is a collective review?

 

[Professor B]

I cry "foul," sir. No serious pipe smoker would laugh at another's preferences, especially when he had the courage to share them publicly.

I realize my tastes might considered weak by some. Nevertheless, I like or dislike a tobacco based mostly on it's flavor. The strength or weakness of the tobacco is nothing to me. If it tastes good to me, I like it. Isn't that the reason we all smoke a pipe? To derive our own special enjoyment from doing so?

 

[JOHN72]

G. L. Pease Spark Plug-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East Flake-​

C&D Pirate Kake-​

GL Pease: Odyssey-​

Cornell & Diehl: Byzantium-​

Cornell & Diehl: Mountain Camp-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East bulk-​

G. L. Pease: Meridian-​

Cornell & Diehl: Yorktown-​

Cornell & Diehl: Blockade Runner-​

 

[ChuckMijo]

Wait just a minute. We have Grangerous. Now we have Captain Granger! Holy moly. ?? . My favorite is HH Arcadian.

 

[Professor B]

G. L. Pease Spark Plug-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East Flake-​

C&D Pirate Kake-​

GL Pease: Odyssey-​

Cornell & Diehl: Byzantium-​

Cornell & Diehl: Mountain Camp-​

Cornell & Diehl: Star of the East bulk-​

G. L. Pease: Meridian-​

Cornell & Diehl: Yorktown-​

Cornell & Diehl: Blockade Runner-​

Yeah, GL Pease is way too hard for me. It's like, "Hey, do you want a dash of flavor to go with your big bowl of nicotine?" Too much.

 

[ashdigger]

You got one right. Amazing

 

[Professor B]

You got one right. Amazing

No such thing as right or wrong here, bub. Only preferences.

 

[ashdigger]

No such thing as right or wrong here, bub. Only preferences.

Bub? Got it there boss, my humblest of apologies, I’ll go hide my head in shame.

 

[JOHN72]

Yeah, GL Pease is way too hard for me. It's like, "Hey, do you want a dash of flavor to go with your big bowl of nicotine?" Too much.

Good,take your time...........I don't appreciate nicotine pump in these tobaccoes.............But it's a matter of testing and repeating............

 

[JOHN72]

Bub? Lo tengo, jefe, mi más humilde disculpa, iré a esconder mi cabeza avergonzada.

 

[JOHN72]

No such thing as right or wrong here, bub. Only preferences.

The important things is that you're happy with what you smoke..............

 

[Chasing Embers]

Black Frigate
Solani Silver Flake
Yenidje Highlander
Angler's Dream
Watch City Slices
Christmas Cheer
Salty Dogs
Devil's Holiday
Deep Hollow
Three Year Matured Virginia

 

[JOHN72]

Black Frigate
Solani Silver Flake
Yenidje Highlander
Angler's Dream
Watch City Slices
Christmas Cheer
Salty Dogs
Devil's Holiday
Deep Hollow
Three Year Matured Virginia

100% ? ?

 

[kcghost]

G.L Pease - Six Pence
G.L. Pease - Stonehenge
C&D - Mad Fiddler
HH Rustica
Escudo

 

[saltedplug]

Dark Flake X 5
Black Rope X 2
Brown Rope X 2
Escudo X 3