What Cigar Are You Smoking? 2025

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

geoffs

Starting to Get Obsessed
Sep 21, 2022
297
1,069
Ontario
Finally got around to trying a Stillwell Star. The Bayou is going to be discontinued and so I snagged some to try while I still could. I'm a perique lover so I was very excited for this.
It was... underwhelming. The cigar leaf was quite mild - tasty, but mild. I think this is necessary to allow for the pipe tobacco to not get overwhelmed by the stronger leaf. If I didn't know there was perique in this, I never would have guessed. It was a tasty cigar but the burn was a big issue. I guess the smaller bits of tobacco in the filler burn a lot faster than the wrapper and so tunneling was a big issue. If I smoked it slower, it needed a lot of relights. And the last third got very hot and the cigar was mushy. Not an optimal cigar experience, which might explain why these aren't more popular. Curious if others had the same experience.
1754573328769.jpeg
 

Hutch Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Mar 12, 2022
694
4,967
Charlotte, NC
Finally got around to trying a Stillwell Star. The Bayou is going to be discontinued and so I snagged some to try while I still could. I'm a perique lover so I was very excited for this.
It was... underwhelming. The cigar leaf was quite mild - tasty, but mild. I think this is necessary to allow for the pipe tobacco to not get overwhelmed by the stronger leaf. If I didn't know there was perique in this, I never would have guessed. It was a tasty cigar but the burn was a big issue. I guess the smaller bits of tobacco in the filler burn a lot faster than the wrapper and so tunneling was a big issue. If I smoked it slower, it needed a lot of relights. And the last third got very hot and the cigar was mushy. Not an optimal cigar experience, which might explain why these aren't more popular. Curious if others had the same experience.
View attachment 408968
Same exact experience.
 

BenMN

Lifer
Jun 21, 2023
3,301
52,599
St. Paul, MN
Having a a Cigars International Knock-off of a Cohiba Churchill, 6 7/8" x 48 on the porch. It’s 77⁰ F with a nice light breeze. It feels good to be outside after being laid up in bed for several days.

View attachment 409183

View attachment 409181
You get sick?

That Smokingpipes/Blackbird Lancero, watching the moon rise over the big lake

1000011104.jpg
Underfilled but 92% humidity (@71F) is helping. A perfectly fine smoke but I don't see myself seeking more. This was a holiday gift from family that I am with right now so that's nice
 
Dec 3, 2021
6,293
56,087
Pennsylvania & New York
You get sick?

That Smokingpipes/Blackbird Lancero, watching the moon rise over the big lake

View attachment 409231
Underfilled but 92% humidity (@71F) is helping. A perfectly fine smoke but I don't see myself seeking more. This was a holiday gift from family that I am with right now so that's nice

I suppose so—I patched some mortar on a retaining wall on the side of our property in 90⁰+ heat last week. I sweated a lot and konked out for a nap before properly rehydrating; even though I drank tons of water after waking up, this ultimately resulted in joint inflammation in my right foot later in the week. I’m annoyed because I could’ve easily prevented this; I missed a family function I wanted to attend this past weekend because of it.
 

andysc83

Starting to Get Obsessed
Dec 30, 2012
247
3,734
42
Laurens, South Carolina
dojo_6894b29b6c5be-678x900.jpg
 

Brendan

Lifer
I suppose so—I patched some mortar on a retaining wall on the side of our property in 90⁰+ heat last week. I sweated a lot and konked out for a nap before properly rehydrating; even though I drank tons of water after waking up, this ultimately resulted in joint inflammation in my right foot later in the week. I’m annoyed because I could’ve easily prevented this; I missed a family function I wanted to attend this past weekend because of it.
Water is overrated - Powerade or Gatorade works wonders, especially the bulk powder/mix your own.
Forgot the recommended dosage, jam 3-4 scoops in a small glass of water and you'll be right in no time
 

Brendan

Lifer
Haven't taken any photos and I haven't been smoking much lately, just 2 cigars in the past month.

Aladino Vintage Rothschild which was typically top notch from Aladino - big fan of their stuff. Smoked that one on a cold Canberra night out with colleagues so couldn't really analyse it but will buy again, down the line.

Joya de Nicaragua Clasico Medio Siglo.
Fantastic aroma, huge smoke output but too much pepper/spice on the retrohale.
Flavor was good but not sure if I'd buy again. Maybe Nicaraguan tobacco is not my thing.
 

BronzeAgePiper

Starting to Get Obsessed
Sep 28, 2023
282
2,529
Boone>Wilmington
Haven't taken any photos and I haven't been smoking much lately, just 2 cigars in the past month.

Aladino Vintage Rothschild which was typically top notch from Aladino - big fan of their stuff. Smoked that one on a cold Canberra night out with colleagues so couldn't really analyse it but will buy again, down the line.

Joya de Nicaragua Clasico Medio Siglo.
Fantastic aroma, huge smoke output but too much pepper/spice on the retrohale.
Flavor was good but not sure if I'd buy again. Maybe Nicaraguan tobacco is not my thing.
Honduran gang yeaah

IMG_5484.gif