What Cigar Are You Smoking? 2025

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Rockyrepose

Lifer
Oct 16, 2019
1,532
15,115
Wyoming USA
I have some of the older (original) versions of these in the humi which i bought probably 15+ years ago. How was this one? I noted some of these made by Illusione in a cigar shop in Ocala, FL not too long ago and was curious, but didn't pick one up due to the two fists full of other things i was after at the time. Would be an interesting comparison smoke tho!

Had a Tabernacle today out in the sun.

View attachment 407365
I have a love hate with the Illusione version of the One Off. I had the larger vitola quite a while ago and it wasn't that great at the time, bitter if I recall. I don't think I got through it, this was much better and I nubbed it. I might have even blistered my upper lip off it LOL.
I really do feel like two identical blends can come off completely differently depending on what I ate, time of day, length of time in the humi or even my mood. Definitely vitola can play a role too. I would have liked to try the original for sure!
 

Bbailey324

Lifer
Jun 29, 2023
3,127
45,452
Austin, TX
Oliva Double Robusto second this evening. I've had good luck with these, improving with time in the humidor. The one I grabbed tonight maybe should have been a 3rd. Tight draw, vegetal off notes, just generally not so good. Oh well, likely won't finish it unless it improves rather miraculously. Luck of the draw.

Oliva_DblRob_2nd_01.jpg
 

Rockyrepose

Lifer
Oct 16, 2019
1,532
15,115
Wyoming USA
Wow that looks great- not too long or too short. You got rattlers there?
Not up there, I've never seen them on that trail. It's a steep one too somewhere around 1100 ft elevation but not one leafs of three, not even a mosquito. You come up one side of the valley and cut across the creek at the top then down the other side. I came up on the other side in that last photo and was on my way down when I stopped for some 20th anniversary XX dark.
1000006734.jpg1000006730.jpg1000006738.jpg
 
Last edited:

andysc83

Starting to Get Obsessed
Dec 30, 2012
247
3,734
42
Laurens, South Carolina
dojo_688972f52ae3c-678x900.jpg