Reading through this thread I was struck by just how many blends people recommend. I tallied up the blends and 32 different blends were recommended. That's approximately 75% of the entire G.L. Pease catalog. That's really impressive. As stated above, you can't really go wrong if you pick something in your wheel house.
Also, for fun, here are the top recommended blends in this thread:
1. Union Square
2. Quiet Nights
3. Windjammer
4. Telegraph Hill
5. Tied: Haddo's Delight, Filmore, Westminster
My personal favorites are Sixpence, Stratford, Telegraph Hill, and Quiet Nights. Honorable mentions are Windjammer and Pennyfarthing.