Alright I give up, I'm going to order a pound of 1Q and maybe some BCA (although I do have a good supply of another black Cavendish) and give it a go. Seems to come up the favorites list a lot. I usually don't have a set rotation, just what sounds good at the time and I have in stock. Sometimes something I can get local (which isn't much.) Oddly I had a craving the other day for Capt Black, of all things, and bought a pack. Lately I have been enjoying some Dunhill 965, EMP, and some Burley from Boswell Pipes.
Maybe is just me, but many aromatics leave me with a "artificial chemical" after taste later.