Top Three Favorite Baccy List

[group4]

C&D Big N Burley

C&D Elegant Emu

Smoker's Haven In-b-tween mixture

 

[mattmars]

In my limited experiences.
McCranie's Quail Run

P.S Virginia

McCranie's Southern Cream
I'm hoping to expand on this after I open the Secret Santa box.

 

[undecagon]

GLP: Jack Knife Plug, Haddo's Delight, Key Largo

 

[alamowest]

Presently:

Lane 1-Q

Lane RLP-6

McClelland TQ
and looking what to try next.
Mike

 

[weezell]

Lanes 1Q

good ole PA

PS Lux Navy Flake

All good go to baccys...

 

[igloo]

Currently:And for a long time now .

Rattrays 3Noggins

Sillems Black

GLP Picadilly

 

[ejames]

Carter Hall

Prince Albert

Sir Walter Raleigh

 

[rigmedic1]

Only three?
Three All Time Favorites:

Penzance

Sterling Double Eagle

McClelland Holiday Cheer
Three that I smoke all the time:

Goedewaagen

Tinderbox Connoisseur

Dunhill 965/Tinderbox Philosopher/Edwards Special Balkan (They all taste the same to me.)
I dont smoke my favorites all the time because I would tire of them, and then they wouldnt be as special. I treat my favorite foods and drinks the same way.

 

[baronsamedi]

Gotta say H&H Black House, Lane 1-Q and The last is either going to be Magnum Opus or Penzance, but I'm wondering if Penzance is more of an infatuation. I guess if you see me and Hobie calling each other things we wouldn't want our mothers to hear, it's Penzance and I'm hijacking his gettin' places. Tough to stick to three though.

 

[matchstickman]

3 is tough, but here goes:
Orlik Golden Sliced

Frog Morton

7 Seas Royal
Weve got one from each category here. With the exception of Burley, I guess. There are some many others here I could list, but these have been my favorite smokes so far by category.

 

[lordnoble]

Well, if we're saying I can't have anything else other than three, it'd be:

1. Villiger 1888 Mid Day

2. Hearth & Home Black House

3. Dunhill's Elizabethan Mixture
But my top 3 favorite tobacco blends are:

1. Villiger 1888 Mid Day

2. Rattray's Bagpiper's Dream

3. W.O. Larsen Signature Vintage Mixture
-Jason

 

[zanthal]

This thread is a wealth of information in condensed form.
I reserve the right to add my three at a later date.

 

[juvat270]

Currently as this may and probably will change in the future...
1. Mac Baren Golden Extra
2. Penzance
3. Captain Black Royal

 

[vroomfondel]

First place: Sam Gawith St. James Flake

Second place: McClelland Blackwoods Flake

Third place: dunno, maybe Sam Gawith Squadron Leader?
But St. James Flake is the only one I would really miss if it wasn't produced anymore. Fell in love with it the first time I smoked it and haven't had a bad smoke since.

 

[zanthal]

I find it interesting that none of Esoterica's blends made it into anyone's top three except Penzance.
I think I'm going to have to pick up some Lane 1Q and this Penzance so I know what I'm missing.

 

[soylentgreen]

Too new to have a history of preferences to draw from, but so far
GLP: Telegraph Hill

G&H: Bob's Chocolate Flake

Solani: 660 Silver Flake

 

[dylan793]

I don't feel like i've tried enough blends to give a totally accurate answer. However, currently:
1. Rattray's Old Gowrie

2. Peterson University Flake

3. Carter Hall

 

[yohanan]

These are mine for the moment. ::
1: Esoterica's Dunbar

2: Bald Headed Teacher

3: Frog Morton

 

[pawpaw]

Haddo's Delight

Hal O The Wynd

Burley Flake #2
and I am out of 2 of the 3