Salty Dogs - Now I Lay Me Down To Sleep

[pipebuddy]

Plug wise, for me, Peterson's 3P is the only way to go. I bought other Plugs such as Warrior Plug, Wessex's Gold Brick, Revor Plug, Kendal Plug and even Erinmore Plug.

Some are similar to 3P and others lack a lot of body or flavors. But not 3P. It has both, especially after a few years of aging.

And its price is just great. :puffpipe:

 

[peckinpahhombre]

I don't get it. I get tons of flavour from Salty Dog. My favourite plug, just behind revor.

 

[krizzose]

How does SD compare to Mick McQuaid’s Plug?

 

[cosmicfolklore]

I don't get it. I get tons of flavour from Salty Dog. My favourite plug, just behind revor.

As usual, I probably just need to give it another chance.

How does SD compare to Mick McQuaid’s Plug?

Well, it definitely doesn't have the burning cardboard flavor that I find in McQuaid.

 

[lawdawg]

Looks great! I have never heard of Salty Dogs, so I read the tobaccoreviews.com reviews. The "navy plug" history is really cool. Any similar recommendations for more readily-available navy plugs? I'd like to give the style a try.

 

[npod]

Any similar recommendations for more readily-available navy plugs?

Peterson 3 Ps is similar. [Note I said similar, but still different in it's own right]. I enjoy both very much. They do both scratch the same itch for me. Unfortunately, 3 Ps is now on the hard-to-find list.

 

[krizzose]

Ok. I’ll try that again. How does SD compare to Mick McQuaid’s Plug?

 

[mso489]

I think mild blends appeal to specific smokers. Some I really enjoy, and others I can't taste. I do like my rum flavored aros with a sturdy if not strong base tobacco.

 

[peckinpahhombre]

Ok. I’ll try that again. How does SD compare to Mick McQuaid’s Plug?
I have some McQuaid plug put away but haven't smoked it in ages. I don't recall them tasting similar, though.

 

[weezell]

I wasn’t impressed with Salty Dogs.

I agree.

My favourite plug, just behind revor.

You can have it to. Did not care for it at all. But as always, smoke what ya like,like what ya smoke. Were all different and that is why so many different blends are out there... :D

 

[peckinpahhombre]

You can have it to. Did not care for it at all. But as always, smoke what ya like,like what ya smoke. Were all different and that is why so many different blends are out there...

Not a lakelands fan, eh? lol

 

[cigrmaster]

I really enjoy Salty Dogs and have a good amount put away. I found that I can fit 4 whole plugs in a pint sized mason jar. I hate having to jar stuff, but SD is worth the pain in the ass that jarring is.

 

[timt]

Ok ok, you talked me into it. Haven't tried a plug yet and SD sounds really good. 4 noggins has it if you want it.

 

[sparroa]

I'm interested in this one but I haven't been able to pull the trigger. I still have reservations about it - alcohol flavoured blends haven't been my thing...

 

[drrock]

That is one cool knife - where do I get one?

 

[mrenglish]

I liked Salty Dogs. It is a solid smoke but consistent.