Rarest Comoys Ever Auctioned

[ssjones]

I'm sorry Peck, but glad it worked out! Your offer was more reasonable. Pipes with that provenance don't show up very often for sale, so who's to say. I'm betting you will be quite pleased with those stems.

 

[foggymountain]

Congrats Peck. I am glad one of us got it. I almost made an offer on it. Glad I did not, it would have driven your price up. I think the price you paid was quite reasonable.

 

[snagstangl]

I have one, lonely, Comoy, and a number of the seconds. I dont know how old mine is. I picked it up on ebay as you did. It had a crack in the end of the shank with a silver band that just about slides off. The pics looked like Comoy over London, so I picked it up for 20 bucks shipped to me. Hey a Comoy that looked decent for 20 bucks, it was worth the gamble. A nice bent bulldog, and it smokes awesome! Upon inspection I moved the not so permenant band and low and behold it was a London Pride! I have read that London Pride was similar to the blue ribands except with a lighter finish, perhaps for the American Market. The finish is pretty much worn off from being handled by who ever had it before me. Smooth finished, but the grain, The grain is so pronounced that I can feel it when I run my hand accross it, not rough really. It also has that awsome cake that is rock solid and there is no way to know where the cake ends and the briar begins. Anyway, congratulations

 

[micdabutcher]

Congrats Peck. They are 2 beautiful pipes. I'm sure you will enjoy them.

 

[micdabutcher]

Congrats Peck. They are 2 beautiful pipes. I'm sure you will enjoy them.

 

[kashmir]

Peck - The thing people love most about their vintage Comoys are the stems. They are made out of vulcanite, not acrylic. They carry perhaps the most complex stem inlay logo design of any pipe. The white C is actually composed of three separate parts, one white, two black. This makes it very difficult to replace a vintage Comoy stem. As far as I know, only one extant artist has ever successfully made a three part C stem inlay logo, namely Adam Davis of smokingpipesdotcom. Also, they are very comfortable. On account that they are cut very thin. As a clencher no stem is more comfortable. Perhaps the best place to learn about Comoys, aside from Pipedia and the late Derek Greene, who was to Comoy what JC Loring was to Dunhill, is Neill Archer Roan's blog Passion4Pipes and the eBay sale writeups of Mr. Can, who does solid justice to perpetuating the interest in vintage Comoys, by his meticulous researched highly accurate ramblings. Enjoy those pipes!

 

[dragonslayer]

Grats Peck, a definite great investment. I had a feeling you'd pull the trigger on them. Posting "Cool pipes" was such a give away :P
Craig

 

[dmcmtk]

Two really great pipes. If you are looking for "smoking stems" with a three part C, look at Walker Briar, I've never had one made, but he does show them as an option on his site.
Dave

 

[docwatson]

Peck, congrats on some really rare and collectible examples pf the finest Comoy's ever made. I know collectors that pay the same $$ for some vintage Barling Quaints and the Barlings are more common than those Comoy pipes. I think you did really well with those beauties amd hope you do smoke them and enjoy.

 

[philobeddoe]

Good investment Peck, as the saying goes.....they ain't making any more of them! I'm just glad they went to someone who will actually smoke them and not just pop them in the safe.

 

[kashmir]

Wow, this thread has legs!

Make sure to post some photos when they come in.

And, if you decide to smoke them, be sure to let us know what blend you choose.

 

[cigrmaster]

peck, congrats buddy, i hope they smoke great for you. We need detailed review when you get those beauties in.

 

[allan]

Holy Smoke!!!
NY Horseman is Rudy.
Some of you may remember a few weeks ago I posted about a fellow who came to the NY Pipe club meeting named "Rudy". He is a upstate NY quarter horse trainer and had been collecting and smoking pipes in his past, but gave it up due to some family issues.
I sat next to him and he broke open a tin of Balkan Sobraine Mixture number 759. I loved it so, he just gave it to me!!!
This must be the seller of those Comoys. He brought in a whole collection of different Comoy's, but unfortunately, before reading Kash's studies on the brand, i just didn't know what I was looking at.
Holy smoke!
Peck, you purchased some fine pipes here, and from one the nicest pipe guys I have personally interacted with.
Congrats to you.

 

[peckinpahhombre]

I don't know if I will smoke them - certainly not right away. Maybe down the road, perhaps if I get some lucite smoking stems made up. Rudy seems like a nice guy.

 

[escioe]

These pipes have already been smoked, right? So it's not like they're unsmoked and you'll be keeping them in original condition. I wouldn't be smoking these in wind, and I'd probably only light them with matches, and I'd be meticulous about cleaning them ... but I'd be smoking these for sure.

 

[trailspike48]

Congratulations Peck, I hope you get the lucite stems and fire them up.

 

[sablebrush52]

HI Peck,
Congratulations on your newest additions! I have a few Comoys and really like them. Great smokers! This isn't the kind of auction where one is looking for a "deal". It's an advanced collector's addition. The pipes are worth what someone is willing to pay.
Rudy bought one of my Barling catalogs earlier this year and gave me a very nice feedback comment.

 

[peckinpahhombre]

Ok, I have been a little distracted on my mission here, but I need to figure out where to send these two comoys to have some lucite stems made for them.
I know a bunch of folks do this, but if these were your pipes who would you trust to send them to? And should I indicate to the chosen person that these are fairly unique pipes or not say a word and trust that he will be careful?

 

[ravkesef]

I have two old Comoy's, but not Blue Ribands. They are superb smokers, though.

 

[sablebrush52]

http://www.nightowlpipeworks.com/

Ronni made a perfect replacement stem for one of my Barling Quaints.