Needless to say, this has been discussed at some length over the years. Some just like White Spots (Dunhills) and feel that the price is not an obstacle. I am not a Dunhill guy, but my guru on the brand is our member foggymountain, who worked in a pipe shop in Manhattan as a teenager and has preferred Dunhills to most, maybe any other, brand. However, he does warn against the Cumberland and Shell series. Another member, chasingembers, was disappointed with his Dunhill and pictures it used as a planter. I think they are a good old English name and mostly well made pipes, and very sharp looking, but simply overpriced. For $700, which is not an unusual price for a new Dunhill, I think most could find two or three higher end pipes that would please them as much. I think the same disparity at a lower level exists in the estate (used) pipe market. But if you crave one, and can afford it without undue sacrifice, it might be good to purchase one and see how you like it. They've never been worth that price, new or estate, to me. As a disclaimer, I will admit, I am someone who greatly enjoys MM cobs, a Kaywoodie Drinkless, and a Yello-Bole briar, as well as a number of middle priced and some up-market pipes too.