Jackknife Plug.
I'm halfway through my first tin and it's sort of mysterious to me. I've tried in a few different pipes, different sizes and aspect ratios, and maybe once every ten puffs I get this amazing, dark, smoky note. But the overriding note is spice, weirdly, so much so that I tried smoking it out of a pipe that never sees perique. But it was still spicy, not really in the perique way, but more in the way that a good cigar can be spicy. Anyway, I really like the blend, but I feel I've got a lot of technique refining to do to make the smoke more consistent to me. I've tried cutting into flakes of various sizes and fully rubbing it out, but maybe the old fold & stuff will work better for me.
So try Jackknife Plug.