They're both good lines of pipes. I like my Castellos, mostly the Dunhills went into the drawer when I started smoking Barlings, though there are several that I still smoke. But why not include Ser Jacopo or Upshall, maybe Charatan or Radice? Then there's Ardor, Kaywoodie, Sasieni, Stanwell, Savinelli, Ashton, Ferdnown, Caminetto, Bauer, GBD, BBB, and LSMFT? And leave us not forget MM cobs which, along with the aforementioned brands, smoke as well as any other pipe.