20 Lbs, That's the Limit

[cosmicbobo]

19 pounds 15 ounces of Corn Cob Pipe and Button Nose

The extra space is cobwebbed rat infested waiting for 1 friggin ounce of Penzance (since I ran out of CB Grape).
PS - If anyone takes any part of this seriously... Keep going. After you're committed I may get some fargin penzance.

PS - I really am kidding

 

[cosmicbobo]

didimauw, I totally hear ya

 

[sablebrush52]

Do I really need to answer this?

Seriously, why would you think you would "need" to respond? Is someone holding your gerbil at gunpoint, demanding that you answer the question? It's just a hypothetical question, yours to ignore, like anyone here, or any thread here.
I find the answers very interesting because there's such diversity.

 

[anthonyrosenthal74]

Oh crap... totally unfair question :rofl:
Black Frigate 4 lb

Blue Mountain 4 lb

Lane BCA 3 lb

Blend For Cary Grant 2 lb

McClelland Navy Cavendish 2 lb

Rattray's Bagpiper's Dream 3 lb

W.O. Larsen's Signature 2 lb
I feel like I'm leaving out a bunch of great blends but this will have to do.

 

[metalheadycigarguy]

I'd go with the following...
2 lbs SPC - Mississippi River

2 lbs SPC - Plum Pudding

2 lbs McClelland - Frog Morton Cellar

2 lbs McClelland - Blue Mountain

1 lbs McClelland - 5100 Red Cake

2 lbs Samuel Gawith - Skiff Mixture

2 lbs Samuel Gawith - Perfection

2 lbs Dunhill - Early Morning Pipe

1 lbs Dunhill - Flake

2 lbs AC Peterson - Escudo Navy Deluxe

1 lbs Cornell & Diehl - Star of the East

1 lbs Lane Limited - 1Q

 

[okiebrad]

I'm sorry chasingembers I'm calling BS. Along with your Black Frigate and Old Dark Fired you have a hidden stash of Exotic Orange.
Personally I'm going with;
Black Frigate

Pirate Kake

Royal Yacht

Bengal Slices

Exotic Orange

Billy Bud

Luxury Navy Flake

Sextant

Exotique

C&D Latakia just in case

2 lbs each

 

[anthonyrosenthal74]

I'm sorry chasingembers I'm calling BS. Along with your Black Frigate and Old Dark Fired you have a hidden stash of Exotic Orange.

I too found it odd that he didn't include that one. I actually added it to mine but then took it off in favor of an extra pound of a couple other blends... What I hide in a box buried underground, nobody has to know.... :mrgreen:

 

[Chasing Embers]

Out of all of my blends, BF, and ODF would be the two I would have to have.

 

[hawky454]

5 pounds Condor Plug

5 pounds Erinmore Flake

5 pounds 1792 Flake

2.5 pounds Cabbies Mixture

2.5 pounds Medal of Valor

 

[sablebrush52]

Great responses! I realize that as much as I like certain blends, I get bored with them if I smoke them too often. Many are all day smokes for me, but none are all week smokes for me. I used to be that guy who had one or two blends that were smoked for years on end. Not anymore. So I thought that picking a rational modest moderate cellar amount and asking myself what, of all the brands I have, would I condense down to, could be an interesting exercise.

 

[smokeyweb]

5# Escudo

5# FVF

5# Penzance

5# Nightcap

 

[deathmetal]

12 lbs: Royal Yacht

8 lbs: Burley Flake #1

 

[noquarter]

Very interesting question. Anyways,this would be my smoking stash:
Irish flake - 2lbs

Brown bogie - 2lbs

Morley's Best - 4lbs

Haunted Bookshop - 4lbs

Stormfront - 4lbs

Sutliff Ready rubbed match - 4lbs

 

[didimauw]

My goodness Sable, it was but a mere joke! I'ts not that I didn't want to answer it, but I believe most would already know what my answer would be. I think most here would know It would be nothing but 20 lbs of Carter Hall. After all, there is nothing better. I just think people get sick of hearing me talk about it. I'm a boring, simple, one blend man. ::

 

[johnbarleycorn]

Dang this was harder than I thought.....
4lb SG FVF

3lb F&T cut Va plug

1lb PS LNF

1lb OGS

1lb GLP Sixpence

1/2lb Old Gowrie

1/2lb Marlin Flake

1lb GLP JKP

2lb Stonehaven

3lb Condor Plug

1lb Penzance

1lb Dunhill EMP

1/2lb Presbyterian

1/2lb Balkan Sassieni

 

[bluegrassbrian]

10lbs Tilbury

5lbs Gawith Best Brown

1lb Wessex CBD flake

1lb FVF

1lb Solani Silver

1lb Mcclelland Brindle

1lb Mcclelland St James
(Secret Santa take note :: )

 

[kodos44]

5lbs Rattray Halo O' the Wynd

5lbs Bob's Chocolate Flake

2lbs Bald Headed Teacher

2lbs Three Blind Moose

2lbs Ennerdale

5lbs LBF
Yup 21. Couldn't poossibly do it with 20.

 

[sablebrush52]

My goodness Sable, it was but a mere joke! I'ts not that I didn't want to answer it, but I believe most would already know what my answer would be. I think most here would know It would be nothing but 20 lbs of Carter Hall. After all, there is nothing better. I just think people get sick of hearing me talk about it. I'm a boring, simple, one blend man. ::

Ahh. This I didn't know. Look youngster, you're too young to be a codger or a curmudgeon. You'll get there. Now go out and smoke some Dan Tobacco Holly's Non Plus Ultra and experience life!

 

[oldgeezersmoker]

Easy

2 lb And so To Bed

3 lb Arcadia

5 lb Doblones D Oro

5 lb 2015

5 lb 2035
Now, as far as what I would have in off site storage.....

 

[PaulTheScandinavian]

Hmm, interesting challenge,

Let's give em a try:

2 Lb Amphora Original Brown 2lb Rattrays Old Gowrie--/1lb Dunhill Dark Flake--/1-lb Peterson Irish mixture-/1lb Solani633

2 lb Mc Baren Golden Extra 1lb of Orlik Golden Sliced

2 Lb Tabac Semois de Manile 2lb Solani Aged Burley flake

2 lb HU Tobacco Makhuwa

2 lb Mc Baren Old dark Fired

1 lb Mc Baren Bold Kentucky

1 lb G&H Kendal Kentucky