Your top 5 can't live without Tobacco's

[napulitano215]

Your top 5 can't live without Pipe Tobacco's

 

[Waning Embers]

Balkan Sobranie

Black Frigate

Mephisto

Pirate Kake

Old Dark Fired

 

[newbroom]

I must always have at least one of the burley based codger blends on hand at this stage of my pipe smoking 'career'.

I keep several on hand and savor each.

There's a comfort in knowing that these are consistent tasting and consistently satisfying.

In case you don't know what a codger blend is, they're the typical pipe tobaccos that have been available for years and years and don't go out of style.

My first was (not counting the dreaded Captain Black in the white pouch) Sir Walter Raleigh. You never forget your first. :D

 

[mso489]

Didn't we just do this?
Semois Tobac-Manil

Dunhill MM 965

Nat Sherman 536

PC Midtown Chestnut

PS Luxury Navy Flake

 

[warren]

Not sure I have even one. I suppose IRC 3Star Blue as it will probably be around for years. I'd be hard pressed to pick four others. Royal Yacht and My Mixture I guess.

 

[Perique]

Can't live without? Hmmmm.
Haddo's Delight

Wilke Bestmake

Escudo

Marlin Flake

McClelland Scottish Cake
(a few runners up...)

 

[lochinvar]

Only two are a matter of life and death

Rattray Red Rapparee

Gawith FVF
But I'm really happy if I can have these at the party too.

McConnell Oriental

Peretti Royal

Presbyterian

McClelland Virginia No. 24, Grand Orientals and Tudor Castle

SPC Deception Pass

 

[acutabovebriar]

ESCUDO

DARK STAR

ST. JAMES WOODS

RED FLAKE

STONEHAVEN

 

[freakiefrog]

ORLIK GOLDEN SLICED

ESCUDO

SALONI 633

DUNHILL MM 965

PIRATES ALLEY (LOCAL BLEND)

 

[derfatdutchman]

Old Dark Fired

Escudo

Gaslight

Three Friars

Engine 99

 

[tobyducote]

Escudo

Solani 633

Squadron Leader

Navigator

White Knight

 

[tarak]

Yeah we did just do this, but heck, who hasn't started this thread when they were new to the forum? I know I did.
1. Escudo

2. Haddos Delight

3. Anniversary Kake

4. Christmas Cheer (pick a year, any are fine, but if you'll let me have a lifetime supply, 2001 was awesome).

5. Dunhill Nightcap (gotta change it up once in awhile).

 

[jcsoldit]

1. I have two or maybe three others that are interchangeable with the below group on any given week.
   St. James Flake
   
   Hal O' The Wynd
   
   Marlin Flake
   
   Park-Lane Red Paramour
   
   Bob's Chocolate Flake