jayski :
I have played many times at the idea of owning a Dunhill, after all they are a pipe carving Legend.
All of your comment was quotable, but this part stood out for me.
I felt the very same way in the first year I found this forum which coincided with my first year of piping.
Consequently, I did find 'the hunt' for good pipe values on the auction site to be a focus of my attention for many happy hours.
A Dunhill was won for $67.00, and it was not in bad shape, except that the stem didn't have a dot. It was a replacement.
That wouldn't do. I read up on replacement stems for Dunhill and found that there was one 'certified' Dunhill replacement guy and I sent the pipe to him for the 'real deal'. The 'real deal' cost me more than the pipe!
I didn't even smoke this thing for over a year or more, but once maybe. I was hanging on to it as an 'investment', thinking I could 'make money' selling it for more than I'd paid.
But, I realized that as long as it sat in my rack, that itch for acquiring what seemed the most iconic brand and yes even model (a 1954 1/2 bent Shellbriar) was gone, absent, satisfied.
So, now I rotate that sucker, and it's fun to smoke. It is my 'most expensive' pipe, too!