Ok, nice. I thought it was good quality. How would you describe its smell and flavor compared to other blends like OGS and Capstan?FVF has got to be one of my favorites.
So I gave it some serious thought and pondering. Finally it hit me why they are packed so wet.I have been trying for months to get some Samuel Gawith Full Virginia Flake. It is held in high esteem in reviews by those who love pure Virginia. Finally, a week ago, I found some on Watch City and ordered three tins along with some Brown Flake. Anyway, it arrives and I pop the tin and while I know Sam Gawith is known for moist packing, I could almost wring out the juice from these flakes. I opened the tin, rubbed one flake out and let the whole kit-kaboodle sit and dry for a couple of hours. Loaded it in a cob and while it tasted good, it was still so wet I could hardly finish the bowl.
I know they still use the old equipment from over a hundred years ago, in their processing and it is done the "old way" but does anyone know why their tobacco is so wet??? Is there a reason they consistently do so?
Yeah they stopped vacuum sealing them a while ago but even when they did it was still wet probably wetter. Doesn't bother me.So I gave it some serious thought and pondering. Finally it hit me why they are packed so wet.
I came to the only conclusion could be because those square tins dry out so damn quickly!
I can't really speak for OGS as it's been quite a long time since I've smoked any, but I did just finish a tin of Capstan and I would say the most notable difference for me is that Capstan has that plum flavored topping that's very noticeable in the taste and aroma. FVF on the other hand just straight Virginia, or if there is a topping I don't notice it. It's a nice mature Virginia flake and I would recommend it if you're looking for such. It's really good when it gets age on it.Ok, nice. I thought it was good quality. How would you describe its smell and flavor compared to other blends like OGS and Capstan?
I've only had one tin of Capstan and it was a few years ago and I remember it being very good, but don't remember much else about it.Ok, nice. I thought it was good quality. How would you describe its smell and flavor compared to other blends like OGS and Capstan?
Plum smelling smoke is one of my long held connotations of pipe smoking, maybe going back to Prof. Plum with his pipe in the game Clue.I can't really speak for OGS as it's been quite a long time since I've smoked any, but I did just finish a tin of Capstan and I would say the most notable difference for me is that Capstan has that plum flavored topping that's very noticeable in the taste and aroma. FVF on the other hand just straight Virginia, or if there is a topping I don't notice it. It's a nice mature Virginia flake and I would recommend it if you're looking for such. It's really good when it gets age on it.
I had SG Best Brown Flake and it does have a Black Tea flavor for whatever reason. It's pretty unique, the only blend out of 50 I've tried to have that Black Tea flavor. I imagine there are other blends with it though.I've only had one tin of Capstan and it was a few years ago and I remember it being very good, but don't remember much else about it.
I've smoked a ton of OGS, and the difference between it and FVF is about as vast as it gets.
OGS is a bright Virginia that gives the aroma and flavor of hay and grass, with a hint of citrus.
FVF has a little bit of that, but the predominant aroma and flavor is much darker. Think prunes or figs. It tastes like black tea and prunes to me and is sweeter and darker than OGS.
That's an impressive photo.Here is a sample of 2013 FVF beside 2025 FVF. Notice the difference in color. No doubt some of the difference is from the age, but the older tobacco was nearly the same color to begin with.
![]()
Plugs are slightly more intense than Flakes; I find this with both FVF and St James. Flakes are great for we lazier folk lol.I had SG Best Brown Flake and it does have a Black Tea flavor for whatever reason. It's pretty unique, the only blend out of 50 I've tried to have that Black Tea flavor. I imagine there are other blends with it though.
F.V. Plug didn't have a Black Tea flavor, by comparison.
That's an impressive photo.
I recall my FVF plug looking somewhere between the two in your photo in terms of color, brown patterns, darkness. My friend gave it to me like it was a 3D rectangle that I then diced.
May I please ask, how much are the Flake version of blends like the plug version?
All the best.
Boy, there have really been some great comments and thoughts on this subject. I never dreamed, when starting the thread, that it would still be kicking around at this point.I can't really speak for OGS as it's been quite a long time since I've smoked any, but I did just finish a tin of Capstan and I would say the most notable difference for me is that Capstan has that plum flavored topping that's very noticeable in the taste and aroma. FVF on the other hand just straight Virginia, or if there is a topping I don't notice it. It's a nice mature Virginia flake and I would recommend it if you're looking for such. It's really good when it gets age on it.
But what room?Plum smelling smoke is one of my long held connotations of pipe smoking, maybe going back to Prof. Plum with his pipe in the game Clue.
I have never had FVF in the plug version.May I please ask, how much are the Flake version of blends like the plug version?
I like that method, Cosmic. I'm gonna try that method.@peckinpahhombre once posted a thread about how he dries his FVF, and I have used it ever since.
First cube cut the flakes. Then dry it till it has just reached a dry to the touch and feel. Then jar or put it all back into the tin. Wait for a week or so for the water deeper down inside those cubes to equalize, and then gravity fill and enjoy. I now do this with almost all flakes, but it is especially important for FVF, because those small cubs can hold water really well, even when it is dry to the touch.
I always dry an entire tin of jar as soon as I open them, because it is ridiculous to be drying one little bowl full at a time. Who has time for that shit?