I'm of the mind, that my spare time is worth roughly $150/h, using that logic, might as well buy a pipe that I like to begin with rather than modifying one I don't!
I'd love to see pictures of some finished ones.Marm, I had that revolting finish on quite a few Dr. G & other estate pipes I'd purchased, even redder, thicker and shinier than the Dr G's. Alls I did was soak them in alcohol for a few hours, take to them with 1200 grit W&D sandpaper for a couple of minutes and then that Halcydon(?) bowl polish - they came up a million bucks and now look totally classy instead of utterly tacky!
I have my first pipe, a Dr Graybow. Bought it in 1964 in Navy boot camp. It was the only pipe I owned for 3 years. I now have some high end pipes from custom carvers but, it seems like every time something significant happened in my life that Graybow was in my face. I smoked it all thru Viet Nam, hunting, fishing, backpacking the western states. When both of my children were born I was smoking that pipe. A lot of good memories with that old pipe because it was a cheap old pipe and I wouldn't mourn its loss.
But now, I can fire it up and revisit goose wings whispering in the dawn, an old lab and other friends and places that are no longer with me. I can relive those moments that are dear to me.
True, a pipe is a tool but, like some tools that we use, sometimes they become more than tools. 'Sides it is now the best smoker I own, 47 years of smoking a pipe will do that.
OK.You guys are doing a terrible job of talking me out of that Grabow.