I can see how the poker shape might leave some cold. It's sort of a snowman pipe along with cobs, many of which share the shape with the tall cylindrical bowl. That's why others, like me, like it. It's basic and simple, and many versions take that simplicity to show off the grain or other aspects. One reason I like foggy's Dunhill poker is that it retains that Dunhill refinement but less of the exaggerated reserve ... if that makes any sense. No? Well something like that.