One od my favorite forums is an Australian motorcycle forum. They argue many times but remain friends. Its a natural dynamic of human interaction to have some conflict. I have seen nothing here that would or should cause any lasting animosity. Rather I see people keeping their disagreements civil. I have never thoight an intellectual challenge to be personal. The challenge of ideas has driven this culture to greatness. So let us all the be adult and understand that we are not all perfect and that some discourse of a challenging nature will and should be a part of normal operations on this platform...as it were.were.
Well said locopony. It is a simple fact of human nature that when anything is "taboo" (such as discussing politics or religion) it will always and inevitably "erupt" at times...and when it does it is often ugly because the suppression has not allowed people to learn how to discuss such things. But when the natural, human need to have an outlet and discourse for such things is accommodated, reasonable people will learn to be civil and polite about it.
There will of course still be occasional flaring of tempers because this is also inevitable whenever passions are aroused...and some of us do have passionate convictions. But that is a good thing, not bad, IMHO. It doesn't mean the individual is just "looking for an argument" (although those types are out there as well).
IMHO, there is always appx. 10% or so of us freaks of nature who actually enjoy discussing politics/religion/philosophy...and it is always like fingernails on a chalkboard to the majority. I would offer the following suggestion, for what it's worth:
Perhaps the forum should have a separate page for such discussions,
the threads of which would not be visible on the front page. Anyone desiring to participate would be welcome, and anyone who does not want to be exposed to such horrors as people discussing politics and religion would not have to be exposed to it.