With the caveat that we must have really different palates (fresh OGS does nothing for me)... It might be that you just need to give the ones you've already got some more jar time to sweeten up. To my tastes, SJF is tasty sweetness itself; it's been a daily smoke for me since I first tried it. In the cheap and accessible department, Comoy's Cask #4 is sweet and citrusy; I already like it, and I like it more every time I go back to the jar. I strongly second the Watch City 558. Been smoking a lot of it fresh lately, and it's nice and sweet, as is Watch City Old Dominion. I also got a sample of a fantastic fruity-sweet VaPer from Watch City called Rouxgaroux, which I gather they'll be releasing soon. Once you figure in 0% sales tax, the WC stuff is actually quite the bargain, btw. To your second question: I've only smoked one tin of the McC Scottish Cake. I liked it OK once I found the right pipe for it (a pot) because it's got a nice nicotine punch and I kind of like the topping, but I probably won't get any more of it for the foreseeable future - no accounting for tastes! Right now, I'm impatiently waiting on my first tin of Kajun Kake. Hope it doesn't disappoint. Telegraph Hill is probably my favorite VaPer at the moment, but it doesn't seem like what you're looking for - lots of earth, and a different kind of fruit.