I would have said H&H Annie Kake, until recently buying some and finding out that it is no longer anything like what it used to be. My latest order of this smelled like horse shit, and I am not exaggerating. I just threw it away.
But now, it is...
C&D Red Carpet
GLPs Fillmore
C&D Bayou Morning
Sutliff 1849
DR Rimboche SJ