There's a lot to unpack here. You can't discuss one aspect without discussing the others as they are all intertwined.
Even in a perfect environment with a perfect pipe and perfect tobacco with perfect technique, there will be moisture from combustion. I believe hydrocarbons separate and combine with oxygen creating H2O. There also seems to be a correlation between heat and moisture. The colder a glass of water and the warmer the room, the more condensation forms outside the glass. I presume then with a pipe, the hotter the pipe and cooler the environment, the more moisture forms inside the pipe. Everything being perfect, a cool smoke can be achieved but some degree of heat/warmth cannot be avoided.
A pipe's engineering can also cause condensation and thus moisture from turbulence. Sometimes, this is an undesired consequence of poor engineering. Sometimes this is by design such as a Peterson system pipe or any pipe with a stinger. Proper technique can reduce this condensation significantly, however. I have been able to smoke a Peterson system pipe without anything in the well after I finish. I've also smoked an old Kaywoodie with only the finest condensation forming on the metal stinger; as it understandably would. Wiping the stinger once or twice during the smoke results in a dry pipe when I'm done.
I think everything I've said so far is mostly agreeable. But, there are some things I feel are less understood.
I'm not sure how cuts might play a role in all of this. I'm sure it is not insignificant. But, some claim that wet tobacco will result in a wet smoke; dry your tobacco to reduce moisture. Some claim that tobacco that is too dry will vaporize and burn too hot. Some claim that packing a pipe too loose will cause it to burn as quick as gunpowder. Some claim that packing a pipe too tight will cause the smoker to pull hard to get smoke in the mouth, creating a large ember and creating more heat.
There's obviously a middle ground in all of this. Yet, some smokers can seemingly smoke the wettest tobacco bone dry. Some can sip overly dry tobacco so lightly that it does not create excessive heat. Some can smoke the lightest gravity fills without issue. And some pack their pipe like a jackhammer while keeping the smoke cool and dry.
My question is, given the variety of opinions on these matters, it is all a matter of technique? With enough practice, could one smoke wet tobacco, dry tobacco, gravity fills, and jackhammer packs all the same?
Even in a perfect environment with a perfect pipe and perfect tobacco with perfect technique, there will be moisture from combustion. I believe hydrocarbons separate and combine with oxygen creating H2O. There also seems to be a correlation between heat and moisture. The colder a glass of water and the warmer the room, the more condensation forms outside the glass. I presume then with a pipe, the hotter the pipe and cooler the environment, the more moisture forms inside the pipe. Everything being perfect, a cool smoke can be achieved but some degree of heat/warmth cannot be avoided.
A pipe's engineering can also cause condensation and thus moisture from turbulence. Sometimes, this is an undesired consequence of poor engineering. Sometimes this is by design such as a Peterson system pipe or any pipe with a stinger. Proper technique can reduce this condensation significantly, however. I have been able to smoke a Peterson system pipe without anything in the well after I finish. I've also smoked an old Kaywoodie with only the finest condensation forming on the metal stinger; as it understandably would. Wiping the stinger once or twice during the smoke results in a dry pipe when I'm done.
I think everything I've said so far is mostly agreeable. But, there are some things I feel are less understood.
I'm not sure how cuts might play a role in all of this. I'm sure it is not insignificant. But, some claim that wet tobacco will result in a wet smoke; dry your tobacco to reduce moisture. Some claim that tobacco that is too dry will vaporize and burn too hot. Some claim that packing a pipe too loose will cause it to burn as quick as gunpowder. Some claim that packing a pipe too tight will cause the smoker to pull hard to get smoke in the mouth, creating a large ember and creating more heat.
There's obviously a middle ground in all of this. Yet, some smokers can seemingly smoke the wettest tobacco bone dry. Some can sip overly dry tobacco so lightly that it does not create excessive heat. Some can smoke the lightest gravity fills without issue. And some pack their pipe like a jackhammer while keeping the smoke cool and dry.
My question is, given the variety of opinions on these matters, it is all a matter of technique? With enough practice, could one smoke wet tobacco, dry tobacco, gravity fills, and jackhammer packs all the same?
Last edited:
into the stem...dam it! 
I feel like I'd have to see it to believe it 
