Tobacco suggestions?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
4,960
14,356
Humansville Missouri
So Ive smoked cigarettes and cigars since I was 15 I'm a few days a way from 40. When I first smoked a pipe I bought black cavendish and it tasted like nothing I have ever had. So I went crazy and tried a ton of aromatics mostly with black cavendish. Then I tried English which is now my favorite particularly Latakia. Again it's like nothing Ive ever had. Next week I'm going to get something new but Ive notice very similar flavors with all the aros and Latakia blends or English. Like Match Revelation, Match Barking Dog, Early Morning, Nightcap, all are great but similar.


Any suggestions for something new thats nothing like any of those things? Side note cost isn't an issue, and I don't care about nicotine lvl either way high or low.
Try Peter Stokkebye Luxury Navy Flake:


I have six pounds aging and I’m smoking on two more.

PS Luxury Navy Flake is a flake Va Per, probably the most widely sold.
 

bullet08

Lifer
Nov 26, 2018
10,340
41,823
RTP, NC. USA
Started smoking cigarettes at 12 and now I'm 55. Still like cigarettes. Pipe tobacco doesn't taste like cigarettes. But after you smoke pipes for awhile, you will notice cigarettes taste like pipe tobacco. You will pick out sweetness of Virginia. Also if you are new to pipe, you might experience cigarettes like taste from some pipe tobacco. Not because they actually taste like cigarettes, but your palate isn't trained to pick out certain subtle flavors. Truth is, we really can't tell which blends will taste like cigarettes since it's your tongue.
 

Coreios

Lifer
Sep 23, 2022
1,637
2,722
42
United States Of America
Okay I took y'all's advice ordered some Haunted book store, Autumn Evenings or what ever it was called, I forgot. And a few others that were mentioned. Next week I'm gonna order a few more that were mentioned. I also got a wind cap for $2 bucks, hopefully it works. I'm under a ceiling fan, and my wife gets hot. She keeps it on all winter while I freeze to death next to the heater. lol Anyways thanks guys!
 

crossroads

Lurker
Jan 6, 2018
22
59
South of England
You might try Peterson Royal Yacht, it’s been popular for over a 100 years, which is a pretty good recommendation. It’s a blend of burly and virginia which has a smooth and soft smoking quality with a very subtle sweet plum essence. It’s medium strong, ribbon cut and is very forgiving as it stays alight and burns steadily to a grey ash. It used to be a Dunhill and legend would have it that it was Stalin’s favourite blend.
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
20,978
50,216
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
Cigarettes have Burley and Virginia in it......are those cigaretteish? That's why I've been avoiding those.
Some Virginias and Burleys can exhibit some cigarette flavors when smoked too hot fast and moist. But overall, the types of varietals used in both burley and Virginia blends are different from the very very mild tobaccos used in cigarettes. One isn't supposed inhale pipe tobaccos. They're quite a bit stronger than cigarette tobaccos.

Virginias will school you. But if you learn what they have to teach you, a whole different world of flavors open up.
 

reloader

Lifer
Dec 5, 2021
1,982
23,994
Southern, NM
Okay I took y'all's advice ordered some Haunted book store, Autumn Evenings or what ever it was called, I forgot. And a few others that were mentioned. Next week I'm gonna order a few more that were mentioned. I also got a wind cap for $2 bucks, hopefully it works. I'm under a ceiling fan, and my wife gets hot. She keeps it on all winter while I freeze to death next to the heater. lol Anyways thanks guys!
Let us know what you think of the blends when you get the chance to smoke them. Haunted Bookshop is my favorite blend. @Winterreise turned me onto that a while ago and I've never looked back.
 

reloader

Lifer
Dec 5, 2021
1,982
23,994
Southern, NM
Unfortunately I could not smoke Haunted Book Shop. I found out I'm allergic to Burley after I ordered it.
That's unfortunate. It will put the brakes on a lot of blends for you. I'm sure you'll find a lot of wonderful tobacco that will work for you that omit burley though. Happy smokes brother.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Coreios

Coreios

Lifer
Sep 23, 2022
1,637
2,722
42
United States Of America
So I just smoked a bowl of the Bayou Morning that some of you suggested.

First off, it was ready to smoke no drying. It stayed lit and burned nicely. I like it, to me it was very cigar like. Practically a good Nicaraguan. Peppery with a hint of sweetness. As I also love cigars this was nice. I will be keeping this around.



I also smoked yesterday and this morning the Autumn Evenings. That one is going to also be bought in bulk. To me it was maple but I got a strong deep dark roasted coffee.

What did you guys think of them? Do you think I'm way off? Either way these 2 are keepers thanks for the suggestions. I'm going to continue to smoke new blends. I won't bore you with my thoughts. But was wondering what you guys get out of those 2.