The idea that people over-identify and humanize animals in imaginary and self-deceptive ways certainly has merit, dressing pets in clothes and costumes, and many other more subtle but equally probably delusional ways. On the other hand, in our human grandiosity, people universally distance themselves from other creatures to an considerable degree. As an observation of human nature, I would assert that the people who get most worked up about people anthropomorphizing animals, if you draw them out further, often find it impossible anthropomorphizing other people. This sounds like a word game I'm playing, but I'm afraid it isn't. It is amazing how little a cohort of human beings understands that others' life experience is parallel to theirs, virtually difficult for them to imagine, usually draws a blank. Domestic animals can "shake us down" for food, shelter, protection and medical care precisely because they relate with deep observation and precision. In that sense, they may be somewhat smarter than humans. I appreciate pigs and their intelligence, and I love bacon too. No guru or sage here. I'll cease and desist.
The discussion was on this historical albatross bone stem for a pipe; and the pipe historians in residence were weighing in.