Bob, thanks so much for your post and the informative links, and the perspective they bring to this issue.
Some pipe smokers may want to run away from cigarette smokers, but that is ill-advised.
Smoke is smoke, whether it comes from a pipe, cigar or cigarette.
And tobacco is tobacco, whether its packed into a white paper tube or into a Savinelli.
Every measure that restricts the cigarette smoker, has the same effect on the pipe smoker.
The anti-smoking forces, now a broad and empowered worldwide coalition, don't want people to use tobacco in any form.
The place I usually buy my tobacco, only 10 minutes down the road, is an independent tobacco and booze store. They stock an endless variety of domestic and imported beer and spirits and all kinds of cigarettes. And they have a walk-in humidor for cigar smokers.
They also stock a wide selection of "drug-store" blends and offer 10 to 12 Lane bulk blends by the ounce. All at reasonable prices.
But their profit center is cigs first and then beer, then cigars. Pipe tobacco and pipe accesories are just a blip on the register tape.
If their cig sales take a dive, the joint would close and I would have to find a new place to buy my pipe tobacco.
Thus, I have a vested interest in opposing restrictions on cig smoking and sales.
Frankly, if some pipe smokers consider themselves above or somehow different from cigarette smokers they are misguided.
The anti-tobacco movement doesn't care how much you paid for your churchwarden or how delightfully aromatic your new $6.50 per ounce blend is. Or that it has an intriguing name.
To them you are just another tobacco user.
And they are right.
To them you are just another smoker.
And they are right.
Do not underestimate the energy or determination of the anti-tobacco movement.
Public smoking -- buildings, parks, city sidewalks, outdoor venues, etc. -- might be totally extinct within 5 years, at least in North America.
I don't envision that smoking in your own yard or home will be illegal, only because it will be impossible to enforce, much like the Prohibition Era regulations.
But as tobacco sales decline, and taxes and restrictions increase, the cost of smoking a pipe might become prohibitive to middle class Americans. As usual, the affluent are immune.
Those who have stocked their cellars will be able to boast and say "I told you so."
The rest of us would have to decide whether we want to pay 15 bucks for an ounce of pipe tobacco.
Now that would be sad.