Who has been shunned for not doing this?
We don't even have anyone that only smokes aged tobaccos, nor only smokes $1500 pipes. Even Peck and Harris smoke fresh tobaccos occasionally out of the occasional estate pipe. I've seen more people attack those of us who occasionally smoke aged tobaccos. I've even seen more people bash us for even talking positive about expensive pipes than the reverse. We have more cob smokers than anything active on this forum than anything else. I'm not complaining, of course we are all needed and welcome here. But, I also like to have fun. Only the most sensitive seem to get offended. And, as I look back at years worth of posts, in this, the best pipe forum on the Internet, it seems to be working.
I think that we agree on way more than we disagree. And, a touch of snobbishness is totally ok, and shows character, for the pipe collectors and the cob smokers. I know that I respect the hell out of our cob guys, and our aromatic guys. Heck, I've made more positive aromatic reviews than anything else. But, I also have a sense of humor about it all. Everyone is welcome to their opinions. Pro or con. It seems to stay in balance. IMO