The One Peterson Pipe I Wouldn't Recommend Buying.

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Jun 9, 2015
4,198
26,481
43
Mission, Ks
thehawsepipe.wordpress.com
Are the SH pipes system pipes with a chimney?
There were two Sherlock System pipes made in 1990, both featured AB system stems.



The “Original” & the “Baskerville” both are system version of then already existing SH shapes. Both are very scarce today and bring decent money on the secondary market. Personally I think the Baskerville System is one of the best looking pipes Peterson ever made and have been on the hunt for one for a long time.

Aside from those two pipes made in 1990 no other Sherlock Holmes pipes are systems, they are classic range.IMG_1868.jpeg
 

burleyboy75

Starting to Get Obsessed
May 22, 2025
168
332
Ohio
Im a relatively new piper, and I'm sure you're further along than me, but maybe this could help a bit or maybe someone else. I had this issue with a pipe of mine and this is what worked for me:

1. I put a "base" of a flake in the bottom of my bowl to "protect" the airway from clogs. I take a thin strip of a flake (maybe a mm or 2 and 3-4 inches or so long) and roll it like a cold cut lunch meat on a tray. There is air in the middle of the roll to prevent blocking and the structure of the flake gives protection from getting too compacted at the base. For the rest of the bowl, you can use cube cut, fold and stuff, or rubbed out whatever. If you are smoking flake, it's obviously easy to use the same tobacco. If you are using ribbon or whatever, you can use some pretty bland Virginia flakes to use as base, or even a flake similar to the type of ribbon cut you are smoking. I don't think it "adulterates" the taste much or at all, but some people would object to this I'm sure.

For these instances, I have also experimented for ribbon cuts by taking the biggest, chunkiest pieces of the blend and twisting them together, preserving some air flow, like in the cold cut. I put this in the bottom. It has worked okay if you don't want to add the flake base.

2. Also in general for this pipe and for flakes, I pack much less tobacco in and tamp much lighter.

I'm sure some of this is common knowledge and I may be overcomplicating things. "Just stuff the tobacco and light it ya bastard" I have been told. But I had problems with clogging and the tobacco not staying lit. "Don't mind the relights ya bastard" I was told hahahahah. These guys haven't had to burn through a can of butane in a day and refill a lighter twice during a smoke. 1 puff, relight, 1 puff, relight, 1 puff relight. It detracted from the experience for me some.

Hope it helps. Maybe just the pipe. Lot of variables.
 
Last edited:

Sig

Lifer
Jul 18, 2023
2,063
11,693
54
Western NY
Ive had my Watson for a few months.
It is a great smoker, and pretty near perfect in fit and finish.
The same with the XL315 System I bought the month before that.
Ive avoided Petersons for years due to all the negative comments I see online about quality control. Im glad I finally got a couple. They are great pipes with a bit of history.
1000007162.jpg
 

khiddy

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 21, 2024
966
4,499
South Bend, Indiana
blog.hallenius.org
Ive had my Watson for a few months.
It is a great smoker, and pretty near perfect in fit and finish.
The same with the XL315 System I bought the month before that.
Ive avoided Petersons for years due to all the negative comments I see online about quality control. Im glad I finally got a couple. They are great pipes with a bit of history.
View attachment 410680
Looooong whistle. That is a looker.
 

ssjones

Moderator
Staff member
May 11, 2011
19,982
15,685
Covington, Louisiana
postimg.cc
There were two Sherlock System pipes made in 1990, both featured AB system stems.



The “Original” & the “Baskerville” both are system version of then already existing SH shapes. Both are very scarce today and bring decent money on the secondary market. Personally I think the Baskerville System is one of the best looking pipes Peterson ever made and have been on the hunt for one for a long time.

Aside from those two pipes made in 1990 no other Sherlock Holmes pipes are systems, they are classic range.View attachment 410656
I might have to search for a Baskerville!
 
Aug 17, 2025
47
14
I have one peterson. I like it. I just dont smoke it enough.

I am trying to avoid ghosting it. Running through multiple blends in the same pipe in an endless quest to find a good one, or two, is not something I want to do with a Peterson.
 

pappymac

Lifer
Feb 26, 2015
3,843
5,981
Slidell, LA
I have one Sherlock Holmes Original. It's in my weekly rotation and I've never had a problem with it clogging or gurgling. It's one of the pipes I will take to the local whiskey & cigar bar to smoke.
 
Aug 17, 2025
47
14
I only have on pipe that clogs.. its one of those little french pipes. cute little pipe, but the 3-4mm tenon results in an airway that is rather narrow. Twould be fine on a straight pipe.

But on my full bent... im rather sure the air way is to small in diamter and is getting pinched off. Have had to shove a pipe cleaner down a few times in a smoke to restore air flow
 
May 3, 2010
6,604
2,128
Las Vegas, NV
My guess is you’re packing the first bit too hard. I would try just dropping the tobacco in the bowl, gravity filling it to just above the rim, and then putting minimal pressure on it to get that first bit just below the rim.

It sounds like to me you’re packing the first bit too tightly, so when you do the final packing and pressing down it’s forcing the leaf into the draft hole causing the clogging.
 
  • Like
Reactions: burleyboy75

irishearl

Lifer
Aug 2, 2016
2,531
4,783
Kansas
My guess is you’re packing the first bit too hard. I would try just dropping the tobacco in the bowl, gravity filling it to just above the rim, and then putting minimal pressure on it to get that first bit just below the rim.

It sounds like to me you’re packing the first bit too tightly, so when you do the final packing and pressing down it’s forcing the leaf into the draft hole causing the clogging.
No, actually my typical filling technique is to gravity fill bowls and gently tamp prior to firing it up, which usually takes 2 lights.
 

HeadMisfit

Can't Leave
Oct 15, 2025
455
318
i have a single system spigot. It prefers loosely packed shag. Is that a defect? maybe as everythign i like isnt shag.