Nope, although I suppose this can be considered a definitional question (I can easily see the phrase "regularly catalogued" becoming a rabbit hole). Before sharing an illustrative list it's worth noting two things. First, the survival of so few Five stars indicates that few were made; if we extend Lee the courtesy of saying a pipe rarely made is "regularly catalogued" since it appears in catalogs of the time then we must extend the same courtesy to other manufacturers. Second, the $25 price point was a bit of a marketing trophy, and your implication that it was occupied by Lee in solitary splendor is incorrect.
Since Pipes by Lee were preeminently an American product priced in dollars I'll limit myself to ten other $25 pipes available in the American market in the late 1940s:
1) Comoy's: Extraordinaire Blue Riband $25, and the Specimen Straight Grain $25
2) Empire Briar Pipe Co: Emperor Straight Grain $25
3) Kaywoodie: Centennial $25, and the Straight Grain $25
4) Marxman Pipes: The Four Hundred $25
5) Rogers Imports: Rarity line $10-25
6) L & H Stern: Special Make line $12.50-25
7) John Surrey: Supreme $25
8) Dick Swift Pipes: Personal Selection $25
One final observation: one price point down ($10-20) was where the real "high grade pipe" action was at that time. It was crowded with models, and if I wanted to compile a list of pipes which competed with the Lee Three star pipe, which I suspect was the bread and butter item for the company, it would be much, much longer.
I always like to learn more about old pipes, thank you.
Lee was something of a raconteur, but he really wasn’t an out and out charlatan.
After 1946 Lee drops the $3.50 One Star, and the customer got a catalog of shapes, and most (not all) you select a shape and send $5,$10,$15,or $25. So only by that measure, was a Lee the highest priced regularly cataloged pike in the world. But the overwhelming majority of customers seemed to select the Three Star grade.
All were “A Limited Edition”. Probably limited to as many as he could sell.
I think the claim of limited edition was based on small changes to the stinger.
I might count them, someday, but I own at least 60 Lee pipes.
Not a single one, is a stunning, oh my God look at that, outrageously beautiful pipe.
Not even my one 5 point star Five Star Grade had the briar polished out to a high polish. Many seem almost matte.
But I just love, how they all smoke, look, hang, clench, and feel to hold in your hand. Even my late push stem stamped star Lees are high quality pipes.
Compared to top end English pipes, Kaywoodies and Lees after WW2 are sort of like comparing American luxury cars to English luxury cars. Ours were made to American tastes. Theirs are more handmade, and quite frankly, better.
But if you wanted to take your new Packard and drive to Las Vegas, or go off with your Shriner buddies to tear up a hotel,,,,Lee was the better Kaywoodie.
There are terrible, awful, cheap Kaywoodies. I own some.
All Pipes by Lee, were considered by their first owners as a high dollar luxury pipe, because by American standards, they were.