The Great Meerschaum Cake Experiment
- Thread starter TheWhale13
- Start date
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
I prefer my pipes' caked up' a little bit, both meers & briars. Just be careful you don't get an 'uneven' cake. Lots of my pipes have a forward cant, resulting in a thicker cake (if you let it) on the back of the bowl. A quick ream, now and then is more than sufficient.
I've seen heavily colored meerschaums that unfortunately broke, and when you look at the inside it was still white. Not as white as the pipe was originally, but very white still. This is because the natural ability of the meerschaum is to express the tars and oils. You could see the carbon in the bowl/chamber, and you could see the color held to the outside of the pipe by the beeswax, and the inside was still white.
Based off the breath smoking video you posted years back, I would think your pipe doesn't get very hot, and where the majority of the color is is where the moisture buildup is likely to be greatest, especially given the way that the smoke is moving back and forth in the shank and stem. Really interesting to see thank you for sharing that. This is definitely above my pay grade but I'm interested to see how the experiment plays out.
People talk alot about these mysterious oils. What I suspect is really the case is there is dirty water from the moisture resulting from smoking, which seeps into the thinner parts of the meer, by the tenon/shank or whatever it is called.
I have observed this with my own meer where the darkest and most amber colouring is where the mouth piece connects to the meer and traps the moisture beetween the stem and bowl. This colour fades as it dries, cleaning the pipe soon after smoking will prevent this colouring in large part, according to my observations.
I would guess that a heavily coloured pipe would be one that has been consistently smoked many times a day over many years, saturating the clay of the meer, and leaving the coloured deposits once the moisture has dried. My pipe definatley colours more if I smoke it more often.
A very simple test of this, and of the porousness and absorption qualities of meershaum, would be to soak a pipe for a few days in a water/food dye mix, then splitting the material to see the inside. One could also fill just the bowl with the dye and see what that produces. Then allow the pipe to dry and see what colour remains.
I don't have a broken meer to try this out, so it's over to anyone hear with an inquisitive and empirical nature.
I have observed this with my own meer where the darkest and most amber colouring is where the mouth piece connects to the meer and traps the moisture beetween the stem and bowl. This colour fades as it dries, cleaning the pipe soon after smoking will prevent this colouring in large part, according to my observations.
I would guess that a heavily coloured pipe would be one that has been consistently smoked many times a day over many years, saturating the clay of the meer, and leaving the coloured deposits once the moisture has dried. My pipe definatley colours more if I smoke it more often.
A very simple test of this, and of the porousness and absorption qualities of meershaum, would be to soak a pipe for a few days in a water/food dye mix, then splitting the material to see the inside. One could also fill just the bowl with the dye and see what that produces. Then allow the pipe to dry and see what colour remains.
I don't have a broken meer to try this out, so it's over to anyone hear with an inquisitive and empirical nature.
Cant wait to see how this colors, the chamber is 3” deep. It’s still an unsmoked virgin… for now.
I may try this on some cigarette holders or on some damaged meerschaum stem extensions.
Often wonder what would happen if meerschaum encountered some black ink or just leaving a pipe soaking in the bottom of a tobacco jar
Why the need for a test? How and why a meerschaum colors has been known for generations, a couple of centuries..
Found these pictures in my Instagram feed from a couple years back. Accidentally broke one of the claws on my CAO Egg and Claw. As you can see, the pipe has some coloring, but where the pipe broke it's completely white inside.




Attachments
How should I corrupt these two specimens before sawing in half? 
Soak tobacco in water for a while, then add those to the bowl.
Now that I think of it, I have a small piece just like those! Hmmmmm
That’s an idea but I was also thinking what if left partially submerged in order to observe if the coloring material “climbs” up the meer like a sponge.
That's an even better idea! You should mark the liquid level too, for comparrison!
This gives me an idea too....make sure you start a thread on it!
I’m curious of this: internal color wet vs dry. Does it absorb all the way through, then migrate to the outsides leaving a white interior when dry?
Make a new thread soon
