Hauntedmyst,
Great piece.
I'd like to think that the early briar churchwardens were based on the clay tavern pipes (where a piece of the stem was broken off before passing onto the next patron).
Like you, I like the look, but not the impracticality - I'm somewhat height challenged, so lighting the things would present problems. Likewise the need to find cleaners long enough to do the job.
Oh for the days when tavern maids would light the pipes for you with a piece of glowing coal or faggot
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the early days of tobacco smoking in the 'civilised' world, working men would order a pipe with their pint of beer. Regulars often had a personal mug at their local so I'm sure that many men would also have a personal clay pipe which was no doubt kept in their mug.
Those who didn't have either would keep the same mug and pipe for the night. [Despite being against health regulations, to this very day patrons in bush pubs in South Australia - which is very Anglo; Adelaide reminds many Brits of home. - insist on keeping the same glass until the glass goes 'dead'. Then and only then will they ask for fresh glasses]
At the end of the night, the tavern keeper would put all the used pipes on a grate which was placed on the glowing embers in the fireplace.
Since they weren't aware of germs back then, heating the clay pipes in the hearth no doubt had more to do with ease of cleaning than for hygienic reasons. [After being kept overnight on glowing embers, any tar would have been turned to dust and easily cleared by blowing down the stem]
I'm sure that men owned their own clay pipes since they're cheap and easy to make.
Naturally, they're prone to breaking [especially drunk fat guys with their stubby fingers] A piece of damaged stem was broken off to the point when it was too short to smoke.
There's a German pipe vendor [who moved operations to the U.S. due to covid] who sells clay pipes made from 100+yo moulds. He has dozens of various types but I've yet to see a clay Churchwarden.
Not saying that they don't exist it's just that I think that a 12" clay would be impractical because they'd be more prone to breaking than a 6"7" clay pipe.
". . . light the pipes for you with a piece of glowing coal or a faggot."
You saying they had gay taverns back then? Huh.