As I mentioned early on when I joined this forum, I came back to pipe smoking after 25 years or so. I used to smoke Captain Black and a Cherry blend. Since coming back to pipes I've dismissed the OTC blends, except CH and have moved toward Frog Mortan, McClelland 5100 Red Cake, Rattrays Barpipers Dream, and MacBaren Navy Flake. But recently I purchased a pouch of SWR aromatic, and a cob pipe for a homeless man at a shelter who used to smoke a pipe. I shared a pipeful with him and was literally shocked at what I tasted. IT WAS GOOD STUFF! And I'm buying some SWR for me.