Simplest Way to Make a Franken-Peterson System?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

AroEnglish

Rehabilitant
Jan 7, 2020
5,150
15,144
#62
So what I'd like to have is essentially the pipe below but as a system pipe:


I thought the simplest way would be to do the following:
  1. Buy a System Standard Rusticated in the same shape (312)
  2. Strip the stain off of the pipe and re-stain it the color of the Derry stummel
  3. Straighten out the stem, sand off the flare, re-bend the stem to its original shape
This is mostly a thought experiment at this point but I wanted to get your wisdom on if this is the simplest way to get the pipe described or is there another way? I should clarify, simplest can mean either the least amount of work or the least amount of money (though I doubt it would be both).
 

jakesmokes

Starting to Get Obsessed
May 30, 2015
272
5,588
29
Michigan
That pipe is already a system pipe basically without a p-lip and a well. All you should have to do is just drill a well in the x220. Very simple to do I’ve done it a few times on Irish second system pipes that didn’t have a deep enough well. Now the p-lip is kinda tricky because a 312 stem may fit in the derry x220. But it would be just a plain black stem. So you would have to keep the fishtail stem if you didn’t want a plain black.
 

AroEnglish

Rehabilitant
Jan 7, 2020
5,150
15,144
#62
That pipe is already a system pipe basically without a p-lip and a well. All you should have to do is just drill a well in the x220. Very simple to do I’ve done it a few times on Irish second system pipes that didn’t have a deep enough well. Now the p-lip is kinda tricky because a 312 stem may fit in the derry x220. But it would be just a plain black stem. So you would have to keep the fishtail stem if you didn’t want a plain black.
Accord to the Peterson experts, what makes a system is 3 parts:

"Charles Peterson’s System pipe is comprised of three parts: An army mount, an internal reservoir to collect moisture from the smoke (patented 1890), and the graduated bore P-Lip mouthpiece (patented 1894 and 1898)."

So I think what it would need is the graduated bore, p-lip mouthpiece.

I think going the Derry route (which I have and gladly would consider) requires:
  1. Drilling the reservoir
  2. Mounting a p-lip stem
  3. Removing the p-lip shoulder (not essential but I prefer that look for this pipe; might as well go the whole nine yards)
Maybe this would be easier than what I initially proposed but the drilling would have to be high on the mortise and not line up with the draft hole (which there might be a good chance of anyway).