Oldmooner, I see the point you're trying to make. I have a buddy Glen, in his 80s, a Veteran of just about every military action from WWII through Vietnam. Paratrooper and combat medic. He still smokes a pipe every saturday, but he could care less what he smokes or what he smokes it in. As long as its up to the task, he's happy with that. Now take his smoking buddy on saturday, also in his 80's, a veteran of all the same military actions, and an Army Ranger. But Al is the polar opposite. Been collecting Charatans Barlings and Dunhills since the late 40's, even owned a tobacco shop for some time. Both have been smoking a pipe for 65+ years and neither one is right or wrong about their choices. Glen could care less if its a basket pipe or a Charatan Coronation, but Al will talk to you for hours about the history of each pipe, the history of the companies, the subtle nuances of blending tobacco, and has a collection of pipes that some people would kill for.
Its different strokes for different folks.
One thing to keep in mind here on the forum, and any other kind of forum as well; If we didnt hash out every tiny little detail of every blend and every pipe, we would all get pretty bored pretty quick...
We'd probably be reading posts about Rasputins appendages in jars.