Samuel Gawith's Black Twist XX

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

MisterBadger

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 6, 2024
742
5,753
Ludlow, UK
I had the great good fortune to have been gifted a length of what at first sight looks like the Ancient Mariner's tarred pigtail, a black pudding, a Boerwors or something the neighbour's dog might have left on your lawn. The card accompanying the gift informed me that it was purchased in 2015, and that some like it and some don't. However, my benefactor's understanding of my tobacco preferences verges on the clairvoyantly predictive...

The bag note was unobtrusive until you took a deep inhalation - then sharp and quite untobacco-like; I don't know what-like. Maybe a venerable, vintage dark rope twist that has been cellared for at least 9 years. Clears the sinuses, though.

A pipeful sliced up nicely into thin, damp ribbons and after half an hour's air drying, burned surprisingly well for a Gawith tobacco. I chose a new morta to smoke it in, considering that it would be a good, neutral medium and that a slow-burning tobacco would pose little risk of the burnouts and overheating cracks smokers of morta pipes had warned me about.

The first puff was cigar-like, full-bodied yet surprisingly mild. A minute later, I began to realise what a powerful nicotine punch it packs. I took it slow, showed it some respect and, as it required a few relights, had a brief rest in between lights with a sup of coffee.

The taste may be rough edged but I couldn't describe it, as others have done, as harsh. The cigar-like mellowness reminds me of Semois tobacco and this, and the way the Virginia leaves are dark fired fooled me into thinking there was a lot of Burley in the mix.
By the first third of the bowl it was definitely a shade darker and deeper than Semois, but the familiar savour of old barn hay was certainly there.

Halfway down the bowl, I thought I detected the occasional, subtle hint of licquorice, then strong, black Indian tea with a strong cigar aftertaste.

By the last quarter of the bowl, tangy deep dark bitter Seville orange marmalade peel added to the not very complex mix of flavours, and a silly smile was spreading over my face. Tasty and strong.

I knocked out my pipe, rather regretful that the experience was at an end. There was a lingering aftertaste of molasses. It had required some nursing and fussing with the pipe tool throughout but that's most likely down to my inexperience of Gawith tobaccos and my caution in smoking a new pipe.

Well, bloody Hell! That was a smoke and a half. You really know you've had one - and I speak as a hardened smoker with a high nicotine tolerance. It's a manly, Old Time-y kind of smoke. It will put hairs on your chest, a tarred pigtail down your back, give you whiskers and tattoo your knuckles with the letters H-O-L-D F-A-S-T. It will turn your pipe into a blackened old clay cutty, and put you below decks in HMS Bellerophon (or USS Constitution, if you prefer).

Should be accompanied by four-water grog made from overproof Navy rum. Hot, at this time of year.

I shall certainly be purchasing some of this beast to lay down for a decade. If I can keep my hands off it for that long.

Many thanks, @jaingorenard !
 
Last edited:

MisterBadger

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 6, 2024
742
5,753
Ludlow, UK
Quite a coincidence. I brought out a 2015 jar a few minute ago and am prepping it for smoking and chewing. All I get from the flavor is charbroiled beef but not much nicotine unless I chew it.
@Chasing Embers - From what I've seen of your posts, I suspect you are a somewhat harder case in the nicotine department than I am... and our senses of taste seem incredibly subjective and vary a lot from person to person.
 

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
45,528
120,928
@Chasing Embers - From what I've seen of your posts, I suspect you are a somewhat harder case in the nicotine department than I am... and our senses of taste seem incredibly subjective and vary a lot from person to person.
The fresh stuff used to leave the smell of an electrical fire in a pipe. It was the subject of some amusement on the forum eight or nine years ago.
 

jaingorenard

Part of the Furniture Now
Apr 11, 2022
777
3,480
Norwich, UK
Really glad you like it. When it's fresh, I get more of the one-dimensional meat thing (though I quite like it). I think now after nearly 10 years it's surprisingly sweet and complex, and the 'rough edges' seem very smoothed off. I like it a lot, and prefer it to the brown.

I generally slice it into very thin coins so it's basically a shag cut when rubbed out, and give it no drying time.
 

pantsBoots

Lifer
Jul 21, 2020
2,383
9,069
It's a fun smoke and what I load up for a cigarette smoker who wants to try smoking a pipe - it gives a relatively quick and significant nicotine punch and the preparation bedazzles the eye.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MisterBadger

Ahi Ka

Lurker
Feb 25, 2020
6,887
32,865
Aotearoa (New Zealand)
I like mixing it with the brown twist…or when I still had some, Mcquaid plug - maybe the ready rubbed would work?

@Chasing Embers do you ever top lip a coin while smoking the rope? It never occurred to me until just now to have the blend (or any other blend) two ways at the same time
 

abecox

Can't Leave
Sep 8, 2010
415
2,896
Cleveland, OH
I got some on a whim cause I don't mind abusing myself with nicotine but I struggled to keep it lit and after a while gave up and went to try something else. I think my mistake was not shredding it enough and not drying it cause reviews like yours are what drew me to it in the first place.
 

The Clay King

(Formerly HalfDan)
Oct 2, 2018
6,368
60,677
42
Chesterfield, UK
www.youtube.com
I had the great good fortune to have been gifted a length of what at first sight looks like the Ancient Mariner's tarred pigtail, a black pudding, a Boerwors or something the neighbour's dog might have left on your lawn. The card accompanying the gift informed me that it was purchased in 2015, and that some like it and some don't. However, my benefactor's understanding of my tobacco preferences verges on the clairvoyantly predictive...

The bag note was unobtrusive until you took a deep inhalation - then sharp and quite untobacco-like; I don't know what-like. Maybe a venerable, vintage dark rope twist that has been cellared for at least 9 years. Clears the sinuses, though.

A pipeful sliced up nicely into thin, damp ribbons and after half an hour's air drying, burned surprisingly well for a Gawith tobacco. I chose a new morta to smoke it in, considering that it would be a good, neutral medium and that a slow-burning tobacco would pose little risk of the burnouts and overheating cracks smokers of morta pipes had warned me about.

The first puff was cigar-like, full-bodied yet surprisingly mild. A minute later, I began to realise what a powerful nicotine punch it packs. I took it slow, showed it some respect and, as it required a few relights, had a brief rest in between lights with a sup of coffee.

The taste may be rough edged but I couldn't describe it, as others have done, as harsh. The cigar-like mellowness reminds me of Semois tobacco and this, and the way the Virginia leaves are dark fired fooled me into thinking there was a lot of Burley in the mix.
By the first third of the bowl it was definitely a shade darker and deeper than Semois, but the familiar savour of old barn hay was certainly there.

Halfway down the bowl, I thought I detected the occasional, subtle hint of licquorice, then strong, black Indian tea with a strong cigar aftertaste.

By the last quarter of the bowl, tangy deep dark bitter Seville orange marmalade peel added to the not very complex mix of flavours, and a silly smile was spreading over my face. Tasty and strong.

I knocked out my pipe, rather regretful that the experience was at an end. There was a lingering aftertaste of molasses. It had required some nursing and fussing with the pipe tool throughout but that's most likely down to my inexperience of Gawith tobaccos and my caution in smoking a new pipe.

Well, bloody Hell! That was a smoke and a half. You really know you've had one - and I speak as a hardened smoker with a high nicotine tolerance. It's a manly, Old Time-y kind of smoke. It will put hairs on your chest, a tarred pigtail down your back, give you whiskers and tattoo your knuckles with the letters H-O-L-D F-A-S-T. It will turn your pipe into a blackened old clay cutty, and put you below decks in HMS Bellerophon (or USS Constitution, if you prefer).

Should be accompanied by four-water grog made from overproof Navy rum. Hot, at this time of year.

I shall certainly be purchasing some of this beast to lay down for a decade. If I can keep my hands off it for that long.

Many thanks, @jaingorenard !
@MisterBadger I think Gawith tobacco is very well suited to clay pipes. I was smoking 1792 Flake in my clay at the Battle of Nantwich last year.
 

MisterBadger

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 6, 2024
742
5,753
Ludlow, UK
@MisterBadger I think Gawith tobacco is very well suited to clay pipes. I was smoking 1792 Flake in my clay at the Battle of Nantwich last year.
I suspect that, when Mr Gawith The First started out making pipe tobacco, there wan't much else to smoke it in: so one could say their weed is designed for clays. Don't forget what I said about cadging some slow match from a gunner or a musketeer at Nantwich this year :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Clay King

The Clay King

(Formerly HalfDan)
Oct 2, 2018
6,368
60,677
42
Chesterfield, UK
www.youtube.com
I suspect that, when Mr Gawith The First started out making pipe tobacco, there wan't much else to smoke it in: so one could say their weed is designed for clays. Don't forget what I said about cadging some slow match from a gunner or a musketeer at Nantwich this year :)
@MisterBadger I'll have to ask them:) I've got a length myself; I should be OK walking around Nantwich with a lit slow match:) Need to extinguish it to go in the church, shops, pub, museum etc though!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MisterBadger