I have a can from 1980 sitting in storage. Never been man enough to pull it out....
Have not, but will. All the talk of plum flavor made me curious.Absolutely none apart from being a tobacco.
Have you looked at reviews on line for either? I think you'll be very surprised.
And that's how it starts ? before you know it you'll be 10 tins in on your shopping cart, wondering what else to add!Have not, but will. All the talk of plum flavor made me curious.
Yeah, SPC Plum Pudding doesn’t have any plum topping.Have not, but will. All the talk of plum flavor made me curious.
Yeh... it's like plum, but not plum. Kinda like a fart smells like sulfur, but not exactly. Either my explanation above is closer to the truth... or else Englishmen back in the day had no sense of taste, so they fell for that flavor as being close enough to a VaPer to satisfy their tastes. Or, they just like things that suck.
Peterson's University Flake is very similar, but with less of a repulsive chemical overtone.
My suggestion to folks looking for plummy and strength is to just try University Flake. It will be way less assaulting to their tastebuds.
Well that is confusing. I'm going searching for tobacco reviews as suggested.Yeah, SPC Plum Pudding doesn’t have any plum topping.
Yep, it’s a Balkan with the addition of Perique. I’m at a loss as to how the name was selected for that blend. Maybe they thought the Perique added some plum notes to the blend? No clue. ?Well that is confusing. I'm going searching for tobacco reviews as suggested.
The not staying lit thing is strange, for me it’s a set it n forget kinda burn. Pack it, light it and 30 min later the bowl is empty! I find this stuff is just a good solid Virginia smoke with just enough of a top note to keep me from falling asleep. Don’t look for any kind of crazy depth of flavor with it. Try several bowls in the same pipe, preferably one that hasn’t had Latakia run through it. It ain’t for everyone, most either love it or hate it. I’m in the it’s good but not great camp. Personally I’ve never felt the nic from any pipe tobacco so I have no input on that frontStill having trouble keeping lit, not sure why.
In retrohale I get a weird imitation fruity opposed to the real fruit note I got from the tin.
The flavor has changed to a nice dark chocolate flavor that I like. I'm still getting the waxy after taste though. I prefer to retrohale and I am finding this blend a tad harsh there but not terrible or anything.
I'm on the fence about this one. I'm smoking my smallest bowl which is a MM wood pipe that I normally smoke Maltese Falcon in. Maybe a bad choice there on my part but I thought this blend was high on vitamin n..no hit yet.
I'm going to try it again in one of my cobbs later and see if anything changes. Not impressed really but don't hate it so far.
Yes, but in UF, I think it actually tastes more like plums, artificial plums, but plums none-the-less. RY tastes more like a chemical mistake that was supposed to taste like plums. I agree, UF has more flavoring, but that wasn't exactly what I meant.One of the rare occasions where it seems my tastes don’t line up with yours! To me, University Flake has ten times more the added flavor than Royal Yacht. Interesting!
I just cleaned most of my Pipes this morning while it was raining. I may revisit the yacht this evening but in one of my cobbs that don't know lat exist.The not staying lit thing is strange, for me it’s a set it n forget kinda burn. Pack it, light it and 30 min later the bowl is empty! I find this stuff is just a good solid Virginia smoke with just enough of a top note to keep me from falling asleep. Don’t look for any kind of crazy depth of flavor with it. Try several bowls in the same pipe, preferably one that hasn’t had Latakia run through it. It ain’t for everyone, most either love it or hate it. I’m in the it’s good but not great camp. Personally I’ve never felt the nic from any pipe tobacco so I have no input on that front
now why in the heck is this the first time I am hearing this!If you like Erinmore, it will likely suit you're palate.
funny thing about nic levels is they're not always the same from person to person. Certain toppings will in some people and not others help the body absorb the nicotine faster. So some can really kick one persons backside and leave another saying it's completely normal. That said the only thing I've smoked that gave me the wow this has a lot of nic is Semios and only if I smoke it too fast.I expected Royal Yacht to be quite a hell raiser after the build-up, and I held the tin for a long time, and Forums members finally exhorted me to open it and give it a go. I was on a strong tobacco kick at the time, but I found it quite comfortable with no particular nic kick at all. I smoked it in rotation and never got it into a jar, and enjoyed that plum tang (or whatever it is). It wasn't at all overbearing to me. I have another tin cooling its heels in its original Dunhill tin.
?now why in the heck is this the first time I am hearing this!
I love Erinmore. I don't smoke a ton of it but it scratches a certain weird itch.