Room Note of Pop's Tobacco

[dublinpiper90]

I’ve been a pipe smoker for around 10years now mostly aros but I have grown to enjoy english alot nowadays, I have searched forms, read reviews, ask fellow smokers, sampled countless blends it feels like but I can’t find that tobacco that is WHOA that smells great to people around me ? so im gonna beat this question to you all. Thanks

 

[AJL67]

@Briar Lee smoking in his office around the wife and hired help I'm sure he will have a couple suggestions, i seem to recall him saying there are a couple blends enjoyed by all. You don't even wanna know from me man this aint even my neighborhood, Im from the west side of Chicago.

 

[makhorkasmoker]

I have a 2 room note theory. Room note one is the smell of the actual smoke—and what is usually referred to as room note. Room note 2 is the smell of an ember warming tobacco. I believe it is room note 2 that appeals to people—certainly to me

 

[midcentry]

I’ve been a pipe smoker for around 10years now mostly aros but I have grown to enjoy english alot nowadays, I have searched forms, read reviews, ask fellow smokers, sampled countless blends it feels like but I can’t find that tobacco that is WHOA that smells great to people around me ? so im gonna beat this question to you all. Thanks

I've been looking for a similar tobacco, and you get a lot of people recommending Frog Morton's Cellar.
I think this could be pleasant to someone who already somewhat enjoys the smell of burning tobacco, but maybe not the general public. Regardless, you need to sell a kidney to get some.

I've also heard that Sutliff's Eastfarthing smells pretty nice, but have yet to test that one for myself.

 

[dublinpiper90]

I’ve herd Frog Morton’s cellar is too but I’ll never know

 

[PA Piper Mike]

When I smoke Lane BCA in my home office, my 1 daughter (who loves most of my room notes) will walk in and sit in my lounge chair and tell me "it smells like a bakery in here!"

As for English blends, she likes Boswells' Northwoods.

 

[Franco Pipenbeans]

1792 gets positive comments from people.

 

[Auxsender]

Bob’s Chocolate flake and Wilke Sweet Smoky Chocolate leave an incredible, sweet pipe smell in a room. Reminds me of walking past the open Tinder Box in my local mall in the mid 80’s.

 

[kcghost]

You are asking us to identify a tobacco just by you like the way it smells?? Good grief. Is it an aromatic?

 

[dublinpiper90]

You are asking us to identify a tobacco just by you like the way it smells?? Good grief. Is it an aromatic?

Im not sure what it is, all of my tobaccos I have which is a lot I never have had anyone that’s around to say it’s pleasant or they say it don’t smell like my grandpas or dads pipe!

 

[Peter Turbo]

What have you been smoking then? Hard to believe an aro smoker of 10 years can't make a good room note.

 

[AJL67]

You are asking us to identify a tobacco just by you like the way it smells?? Good grief. Is it an aromatic?

No that would be foolish, he wants it identified by the way he remembers it smelling, much better.

 

[solideogloria86]

I’ve been a pipe smoker for around 10years now mostly aros but I have grown to enjoy english alot nowadays, I have searched forms, read reviews, ask fellow smokers, sampled countless blends it feels like but I can’t find that tobacco that is WHOA that smells great to people around me ? so im gonna beat this question to you all. Thanks

Are you asking for an English blend that has a good room note?

 

[jttnk]

@Briar Lee smoking in his office around the wife and hired help I'm sure he will have a couple suggestions, i seem to recall him saying there are a couple blends enjoyed by all. You don't even wanna know from me man this aint even my neighborhood, Im from the west side of Chicago.

See that sign that says Rib Tips, we’ll, F it you don’t need that….

 

[MattRVA]

Maybe try Boswell’s Northwoods or Sillem’s Black.

 

[mso489]

My wife tolerates my entire changing rotation of blends with equanimity and I appreciate that. Lately, the blend that rated a praising comment from clear across the hall in the other room was Lane Limited HGL. She commented on it favorably at least one other time. So for aromatics, that has become a favorite of mine. I find it pleasing and tobacco forward too.

 

[dublinpiper90]

What have you been smoking then? Hard to believe an aro smoker of 10 years can't make a good room note.

I don’t feel as if there bad, people around don’t think the same

 

[dublinpiper90]

Are you asking for an English blend that has a good room note?

Both

 

[VDL_Piper]

 

[Sobrbiker]

DAN Devil’s Holiday