I'm going to sell all my pipes except two workhorses, a Millville Smooth Dublin with great grain and a Johs Saddle Biliard rusticated with a wire brush, maybe worth $75.00 for them both. I smoked Dark Flake in many pipes but mostly those.
I think most of you know my answer. My original Jesse Jones Tanblast Brandy. It's my "magic pipe" that smokes everything well... everything! I'd bet if I could fit a cinder block in it, she'd smoke it straight to ash!