Problems solved by a single call to smokingpipes customer service and same to P&C have different results. At this point I don't know if the problem is theirs or mine, but I stay away from P&C, which is difficult for me given Mr. Ouellette's fine blending.
In February I decided to trade two pipes for a Castello to smokingpipes, which I loved, but on receipt not the out-of-round chamber, and I also had tobacco as part of the deal. On the morning they received the return, but after they had made an offer on the pipes, I decided to buy a more expensive Castello and asked them to stop shipment of the first pipe and the tobacco. They weren't happy with that request. So I got both the first and second pipe in hand. But the mild out-of-round decides the issue, and I return it. To do all of this requires talking to each member of their customer service team, but it gets done correctly and amicably enough.
In short, I was a real pain in the ass, and it still worked out. I shudder to think how this would have been handled by P&C, and I don't want to know. Perhaps two things are true: P&C makes more mistakes, and forum members have a very long memory.