Pipe Blend Ponderings by a Grumpy Old Man Who Doesn't Like Anything

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
I was talking with a pipe smoking buddy earlier today about our cellars and stocking up on blends, and it occurred to me that after almost 4 years in the hobby and 3 years of smoking a pipe at least once a day I'm in the somewhat odd position of having never found a blend I liked enough to want to stock up on it.

I've tried over 150 blends at this point and still haven't found anything that really clicked with me. I've tried all manner of Virginias both bright and red, burleys, English blends, dark fired blends, Lakelands, all the codger blends, and both American and European style aromatics in every flavor under the sun; and still just never really found anything I liked the taste of enough to want to smoke it all the time.

It's a funny problem to have considering that I've been a cigarette smoker for 26 years and have never tired of my everyday RYO cigarette tobacco blend Golden Harvest Yellow (which tastes great to me as a cigarette but is strangely awful in a pipe), and before I started smoking a pipe 4 years ago I was a daily hookah smoker for half my life until my favorite everyday shisha tobacco blends Nakhla Strawberry & Nakhla Single Apple went off the market; and I never tired of my preferred hookah blends either. For some reason though with the pipe I just can't seem to find a tobacco blend that I really like.

I very much enjoy the act of smoking a pipe and find it peaceful and relaxing, so I continue to smoke my pipe once or twice a day with whatever blend sounds reasonably appealing that day, and I'm still trying new blends all the time in the hopes that one day I'll find one that resonates with me. I know how to smoke slowly to draw all the flavors out pipe tobacco, I just don't particularly like any of them! It's a shame there's not much of any strawberry or apple flavored pipe tobaccos on the market since those were the flavors I always enjoyed with the hookah, but none of the fruit flavored pipe tobaccos I've tried ever scratched that itch quite the same.

The closest I've found to blends that could be keepers for me have been Lane RLP-6 and Smoker's Pride Cherry Cavendish, which I do enjoy the flavors of for awhile but still find myself tiring of them after smoking them for more than a few days in a row. I have gone through about half a pound of each of them at this point though, which is a lot more than I can say for most blends since I usually don't get through more than an ounce of anything before deciding that I've had enough of it.

On that note, to keep my cellar from getting overly cluttered with Ball jars full of 1 or 2 ounce samples of blends I don't particularly care for, every 4 months or so I go through my cellar and sell off all the blends I know that I have no desire to smoke again. At this point I've whittled my cellar of 150'ish blends down to 37, and I'd like to get it down to under 10 at some point. I think if I do ever find a blend I like enough to want to smoke all the time I would stock up several pounds of it, but that day sure hasn't come yet. 😅
 

SmokingInTheWind

Part of the Furniture Now
Mar 24, 2024
731
3,992
New Mexico
Have you tried the Tabac Manil Semois offerings? These are very natural and totally different from the typical offerings out there. Their Le Petite Robin blend is a Virginia/Semois blend and is quite nice.

You have tried so many blends and genres I thought I would throw something unique out there to consider.
 
Last edited:

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Have you tried the Tabac Manil Semois offerings? These are very natural and totally different from the typical offerings out there. Their Le Petite Robin blend is a Virginia/Semois blend and is quite nice.

You have tried so many blends and genres I thought I would throw something unique out there to consider.

I have! I've tried Reserve du Patron, La Brumeuse, and Le Petit Robin and they were certainly unique; though not quite for me. They all had a nice robust Burley flavor with a particular note that I can only describe as "mineral", or what I imagine a rock might taste like if you were able to chew and eat it. Definitely a one-of-a-kind flavor experience in the world of pipe tobacco, just not one I particularly wanted to revisit after the first couple times. 😅
 

SmokingInTheWind

Part of the Furniture Now
Mar 24, 2024
731
3,992
New Mexico
I have! I've tried Reserve du Patron, La Brumeuse, and Le Petit Robin and they were certainly unique; though not quite for me. They all had a nice robust Burley flavor with a particular note that I can only describe as "mineral", or what I imagine a rock might taste like if you were able to chew and eat it. Definitely a one-of-a-kind flavor experience in the world of pipe tobacco, just not one I particularly wanted to revisit after the first couple times. 😅

I suspected that you had tried them. Well, I’ve got nothing else to offer. Good luck with your search.
 

spearheadbill

Part of the Furniture Now
Sep 13, 2023
898
16,997
Long Beach
This is very interesting and I am sorry that I don’t have an answer for you. I have quite the opposite problem but the same intent. I began trying everything I could get my hands on in hopes of finding one or two blends that I could just settle into and smoke forever like I did my Marlboro reds before I quit cigs. And cigars I am quite happy to smoke the same couple of sticks without a lot of variation or searching for obscure or rarities. But pipe smoking ? I now have about 50+ blends that I love and any one of them could make me happy to smoke exclusively! I honestly like most all of the pipe tobacco’s I’ve tried and it’s been hundreds now. There is only a handful of things I will never ever smoke again and tossed in the trash. I love tobacco. There are many guys who have smoked more and maybe longer but nobody can possibly love tobacco more than I do.
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
I suspected that you had tried them. Well, I’ve got nothing else to offer. Good luck with your search.

It's alright! I think when it really comes down to it the thing that puts me off most pipe tobaccos isn't even the flavor, but the mouth feel of the smoke.

My mouth always seems to interpret the smoke from Virginias as really acidic and they tend to sting the roof of my mouth and back of my sinuses, Burleys always end up turning harsh and prickly feeling on my mouth around the halfway point of the bowl and leave me with a sore throat after smoking them, any amount of Perique in a blend gives me a crazy sore throat too, and Latakia has this weird mouth coating chalkiness to it that reminds me of chewing a mouthful of soot from an old dirty fireplace.

What I've found I do like though is lightly cavendished aromatics. Not super heavy goopers like the old Sutliff blends where they're so drenched in toppings and loaded with Black Cavendish that the smoke has no strength or heft to it, but just cavendished enough to take the acidic edge off the Virginias and take the harshness out of the Burleys while still allowing the smoke to retain a good bit of body. I think that's why I enjoy Lane RLP-6 and Smoker's Pride Cherry Cavendish (which is also made by Lane) reasonably well, since the smoke has still has a good bit of body but also has a comfortable mouth feel that doesn't sting my mouth or sinuses when retrohaled and doesn't irritate my throat or leave an unpleasant coating in my mouth like non-aromatic Virginias, Burleys, and English blends tend to.

There's definitely a balance that has to be struck for my mouth to be happy with a blend though. For instance, while Sutliff's aromatics were too heavily cavendished for my liking Cornell & Diehl and Mac Baren's aromatics weren't cavendished enough and still gave me that stinging mouth sensation from the Virginias and prickly harshness from the Burleys. Lane seems to get the cavendishing and subsequent mouth feel of the smoke from their aromatics just about right for my tastes, even if I'm not always wild about the flavors of their blends.

So, at this point I at least feel like I know what direction I should be looking in. Mild aromatic blends that aren't super wet or overloaded with Black Cavendish seem to be my thing, and having now tried all the Lane blends I'm looking forward to checking out Peter Stokkebye's next! At the moment I'm smoking a pipe of WV Smokeshop's 2025 Holiday Blend, which seems to be a mixture of some mild Peter Stokkebye aromatics, and it's pretty darn pleasant.puffy
 
Last edited:
Jan 28, 2018
15,665
194,382
68
Sarasota, FL
I quit a 2 pack a day cigarette habit 17 years ago. Smoked thousands of Cigars. But I enjoy a pipe more than any other form of tobacco. And I almost exclusively smoke 3 to 5 bowls of Virginia Flake every day.

I enjoy most other blends except goopers. I just don't enjoy them near as much as Virginia Flake. Don't have anything to recommend to you. Your situation seems quite unique. Hope you can find a few blends that check all the boxes for you. If you're set on trying to enjoy a pipe, I'd recommend smoking more bowls per day and smoke pipe exclusively. Perhaps your palate will develop towards some blends you really enjoy. Good luck!
 

khiddy

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 21, 2024
964
4,497
South Bend, Indiana
blog.hallenius.org
There is only a handful of things I will never ever smoke again and tossed in the trash. I love tobacco. There are many guys who have smoked more and maybe longer but nobody can possibly love tobacco more than I do.
I’ll take that challenge. I’ll bet I love tobacco more than you. (And I’m not going to stoop to relying on a photo…)

I’ve *never* thrown a tobacco blend away. That’s how much I love tobacco.

I’m sitting at nearly 500 blends currently in my cellar, and I’ve smoked every one at least once (plus many other rarities I haven’t had the chance to cellar). And I’ve happily purchased a large number of Skippy Piper’s castoff blends. Some of them of course I haven’t liked at first smoke, and they’ve been set aside for revisiting later. They change. I change. Perhaps we’ll come to an understanding.

But throwing away tobacco is not something I’ve ever done. *That* is how much I love tobacco.
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
I’ll take that challenge. I’ll bet I love tobacco more than you. (And I’m not going to stoop to relying on a photo…)

I’ve *never* thrown a tobacco blend away. That’s how much I love tobacco.

I’m sitting at nearly 500 blends currently in my cellar, and I’ve smoked every one at least once (plus many other rarities I haven’t had the chance to cellar). And I’ve happily purchased a large number of Skippy Piper’s castoff blends. Some of them of course I haven’t liked at first smoke, and they’ve been set aside for revisiting later. They change. I change. Perhaps we’ll come to an understanding.

But throwing away tobacco is not something I’ve ever done. *That* is how much I love tobacco.

Your tobacco rehoming services have certainly been greatly appreciated! It's been nice knowing my underappreciated blends have been going to someone who will smoke them and give them a fair shake, and the funds from our little exchanges have allowed me to continue my quest trying new blends to find the right ones for me! 😁
 

HeadMisfit

Can't Leave
Oct 15, 2025
455
316
The problem is to avoid buying things just because they are on sale. Or because you like x, and it's a 60% va 30% burley 10% latakia blend you shouldn't by pirate kake just because it has the same ingredients
 
  • Like
Reactions: BriaronBoerum

RPK

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 30, 2023
983
7,410
Central NJ, USA
Smoked cigarettes for many years and started smoking a pipe about 5 years ago. According to SP I have tried over 40 different tobaccos. I don’t have a sophisticated pallet. I can distinguish mustard from ketchup but thats about it. I either like something or I don’t. For a while I had settled on English blends but have now narrowed it down to either RLP6 or BCA with BCA being my preference. When I tried a tobacco and didn’t like it I dumped it into a large container, English blends in one and all the others in an other one. Actually those mixed concoctions at times are not a bad smoke. And I have narrowed down the pipes I smoke to basically 4 Petersons. An Irish Harp 80s and a 150 and a Red Spigot 80s and a 150. puffy
 

didimauw

Moderator
Staff member
Jul 28, 2013
11,136
39,664
SE WI
I’ll take that challenge. I’ll bet I love tobacco more than you. (And I’m not going to stoop to relying on a photo…)

I’ve *never* thrown a tobacco blend away. That’s how much I love tobacco.

I’m sitting at nearly 500 blends currently in my cellar, and I’ve smoked every one at least once (plus many other rarities I haven’t had the chance to cellar). And I’ve happily purchased a large number of Skippy Piper’s castoff blends. Some of them of course I haven’t liked at first smoke, and they’ve been set aside for revisiting later. They change. I change. Perhaps we’ll come to an understanding.

But throwing away tobacco is not something I’ve ever done. *That* is how much I love tobacco.
I love tobacco so much I became a Moderator of a pipe smoking forum.

puffy