Peterson St. Patty's 2014... And A Dilemma.
- Thread starter anthonyrosenthal74
- Start date
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
- Status
The trouble with going ahead, if you don't like rustication, is that they may repeat the rustication next year,
in a different stain or shape, and then you'd be into it for buying another rusticated pipe you don't really want.
I say, stick to your guns with what you like. Buy them if you like them, and the price point, and not otherwise.
(After a certain age, the years come around so fast, this won't even seem like a sacrifice, just a bit of a wait.)
in a different stain or shape, and then you'd be into it for buying another rusticated pipe you don't really want.
I say, stick to your guns with what you like. Buy them if you like them, and the price point, and not otherwise.
(After a certain age, the years come around so fast, this won't even seem like a sacrifice, just a bit of a wait.)
Everyone is making some great points here. And I'm on both sides. That is why it's so hard to make my decision. Wilson does make a good point as far as broadening my horizons. I'll think on it 
I was also looking at the new 2014 Saint Paddy's Day Peterson pipes. I did not see any rusticated pipes but all sandblasted ones. Being a fan of sandblasts I am going to get one if they don't sell out first because they are flying off the shelf from what I see. If they were Carved/Rusticated pipes I would pass as those don't interest me at all. The nice part about being sandblasted vs. smooth is that the smooth pipes will all have fills that would be obvious in that price line, and the sandblast finish will not show any fills, nor would a rusticated pipes. Good luck in your choice Anthony.
I will probably get one as I am a fan of rustication and blasts. Since those are not your thing, I would agree with the others who suggested getting a regular Peterson.
+1 on all counts. There was a time when I never thought I'd own a rusticated or sandblast, and now I happily own several. Tastes change. I still like my smooths just as much, but rusticated pipes are just as nice to my eyes now.
Also, these St Patty's look like sandblasts to me, which personally I prefer over rusticated.
anthony, if you are weakening, you may be ready for a textured pipe, and these are sandblasts, not rusticated, so
that is a finish that does preserve the grain, though not with a smooth finish. There were only two left when I went
to smokingpipes.com, 1/26/14, and I thought the 230 bent billiard was an especially nice version, light weight but
plenty big enough. If you decide to make a departure into a textured briar, these particular pipes would be a way
to do that.
that is a finish that does preserve the grain, though not with a smooth finish. There were only two left when I went
to smokingpipes.com, 1/26/14, and I thought the 230 bent billiard was an especially nice version, light weight but
plenty big enough. If you decide to make a departure into a textured briar, these particular pipes would be a way
to do that.
So they're blasts and not rusticated? Blasts I might be able to live with. I've seen a few blasts that I really liked. I may take another look.
Anthony I had the same mind thoughts about blasts and rusticated pipe until I bought one they kind of seem to grow on you, I fully think if you buy one you will not be disappointed. With that being said I don't own any Petersons so I can't speak of quality.
~Ron
~Ron
Anthony,
I have the same aspirations. A St. Party's Day Pete, 3 tins of McClelland Christmas Cheer, and I am sure some other annual traditions. I looked at them on a few sites and liked the body, but was hoping for a Zulu or similar shape. I will still get one, probably the apple shape, but am not in love with the shapes I have seen.
I have the same aspirations. A St. Party's Day Pete, 3 tins of McClelland Christmas Cheer, and I am sure some other annual traditions. I looked at them on a few sites and liked the body, but was hoping for a Zulu or similar shape. I will still get one, probably the apple shape, but am not in love with the shapes I have seen.
I've learned years ago, and I'm certainly not just referring to just purchasing a pipe, is to never purchase something that goes against your inner feelings/taste, etc. Usually, you'll end up having that (subconscious inner doubt?), and it's just not worth it. Always go with your gut feeling. I'm certainly not touting smooth, rusticated and or sand blasted as that is your, and or anyone's personal preference/taste. Always go with what you honestly feels right for you and don't be swayed by others. After all, when all is said and done; you are the one that will have to live with it... not us. :wink:
Anthony,
Early in the thread, someone mentioned getting older editions of the St. Patrick's Day pipes. I have been watching eBay for the past week and did not see much encouraging. That is not to say that you could not be vigilant and get some along the way. I have a 2005 St Paddy pipe (Rhodesian smooth finish) that I would be willing to part with, I would guess that there are others so inclined...
Either way, we are with you!
Spencer
Early in the thread, someone mentioned getting older editions of the St. Patrick's Day pipes. I have been watching eBay for the past week and did not see much encouraging. That is not to say that you could not be vigilant and get some along the way. I have a 2005 St Paddy pipe (Rhodesian smooth finish) that I would be willing to part with, I would guess that there are others so inclined...
Either way, we are with you!
Spencer
Anthony:
Just a note for the future:
I've never heard of a company offering similar Christmas pipe shapes/finishes from year to year. In my experience, each year's offerings stand alone, so you can often tell at a glance what "year" someone's smoking.
Pardon me if you knew this already, but it sounded like, from your OP, you expected to be able to get a duplicate pipe the following year.
Bob
Just a note for the future:
I've never heard of a company offering similar Christmas pipe shapes/finishes from year to year. In my experience, each year's offerings stand alone, so you can often tell at a glance what "year" someone's smoking.
Pardon me if you knew this already, but it sounded like, from your OP, you expected to be able to get a duplicate pipe the following year.
Bob
While we've been gabbing, SP and P&C have sold most of theirs. 4N has a few bents, COJ appears to be well stocked. I just ordered a #264.
I'd say just go for it! Even though the rustication isn't your style, it shouldn't take away from the smoking experience you'll get out of it.
I wanted to pick one up last week when word that P&C had it, but I slept on it and the morning after, they were all sold out =.
I wanted to pick one up last week when word that P&C had it, but I slept on it and the morning after, they were all sold out =.
SP has some right now. I just got the Canadian. I think it looks very Irish. This is my 20th anniversary gift. It is on March 17th! Happy patty's day.
I wasn't expecting the same finish, Bob. I've seen later year pipes and it seems they change it up. I just wasn't expecting them to go blasted or rusticated. Last year I got the XL90 shape, which they have again this year and I know they've had in the past as well. Blasts are ok, I've seen a few that I thought were quite nice. And I'm sure the pipe will look better in person than in a photo online.... they usually do, and the green rim is a nice touch.Spencer, thank you for the offer
But I want to move forward from the year I began smoking a pipe. It was a year this January, so I want 2013, 2014, and on from that 
We had 60 and blew through them in a couple of days. We have 70 more that should arrive any day, but St. Patrick's Day pipes always fly out the door as fast as they come in. I think they did a nice job on the way they finished the blasts this year and would probably grab one if I didn't want to make sure that our customers had first dibs.
Russ
Russ
- Status