Peterson 2023 Christmas Pipe
- Thread starter The Amish Tyrant
- Start date
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
I have one (two actually), I just don't bother with the polishing. The tarnish on silver won't hurt anything. Once the outer micron layer is oxidized, it stops; not like steel where it continues to oxidize deeper into the metal.
I have a silver unicorn ring that turned nearly black when I lost it under the couch for a year and a half. After I polished it back up, I put it in a box and it hasn't tarnished since.
I could always put the Peterson in a drawer/box/bag and it would probably not tarnish (or do so much more slowly), but I like my pipes sitting on display on the mantle. It especially fits with the map thing on the wall. Reminds me, I need to clean up and organize my mantle. Bunch of junk up there.
A lot of folks disagree with that opinion.
The band is hallmarked silver, and nicely detailed at that price. Add the P-lip stem, and then I'm interested.
A lot of folks just want the brand. Had it not been for Wally Frank promoting them, Castello would've gone under 70 years ago due to lack of interest.
For real it's the only reason I haven't pulled the trigger on one yet. Can't find Castello that I like thats worth my $$.
Well, you are entitled to your opinion, even when wrong. And "the brand" is an important aspect for many pipe collectors.
The only thing I have an issue with "The Brand" is you end up paying a premium for the name alone.
“Premium” implies so many things.
If what you mean is however the value of the name figures into pricing from the point of view of the manufacturer it figures in then yes, no different than any other product.
Name may make a difference in a positive or negative way, or not at all.
Anyway, I had hoped there might be a tie in to the Holmes line but still wait and see on the particular ones I guess, otherwise there are a couple of the many listed shapes that are also appealing - looks like supply shouldn’t be an issue.
Wanted to check the shape lists, boo no 107, but this made me laugh:
361. SPECIAL BULLETIN: The 2023 Christmas Pipe Drops Friday, Sept. 22nd
D21 The 2023 Christmas commemorative drops this Friday, September 22nd, at 6pm Eastern Time. There are shapes aplenty this year, including one rarity (seen above) and four in the Sherlock Holmes r…petersonpipenotes.org
AKA these are going to look borderline brown in outside of SPC's great studio shots. The fact they're sandblasts probably isn't going to offset the "premium" pricing of the silver band, vulcanite stems and leather bags. So I assume they'll be pricier than even last years spigot models. Definitely a miss for me.
The silver (aluminum I believe) P on the stem puzzles me. They put it on a lower priced release, but not on the POY.
I think it’s because they were trying to keep the POTYs more historically accurate. I wish that extended to the longer ferrule but
Vulcanite stems only, no thank you. 
These have appeared in some corners of the internet, and they appear to be MUCH darker than the release photos. Sort of a dark chocolate colour.
I guess there's a chance the photos I'm seeing are the innaccurate ones and are showing them darker than they actually are!
I guess there's a chance the photos I'm seeing are the innaccurate ones and are showing them darker than they actually are!
Just got a look at them. No B56 and no chamber depth greater than 1.65", going to have to pass. Sad really, I was hoping for a big B56.
Got mine earlier on, colours fine. Think it’s just differences on various site’s photos.
Passed on this shape back in 2017, when it was the POTY because of the short saddle stem. This tapered stem suits the shape much better I think. Nice blast, drilling spot on & I couldn’t be happier with it.
Passed on this shape back in 2017, when it was the POTY because of the short saddle stem. This tapered stem suits the shape much better I think. Nice blast, drilling spot on & I couldn’t be happier with it.
I retract my earlier comment, must have been the photos on the website I was looking at that were off!
If they put the Christmas treatment on one of the big House Pipes, it would be a big hit.