I feel the same way. It’s great to know what you are looking for in both pipes and tobacco. Now that I’m not buying pipes and since I only smoke about once a day, I don’t mind (so much) spending on expensive aged tobacco at Tinbids. Still beats $25-30 for a good cigar like a Padron.I’m currently sitting at 16. I plan on adding a couple more Jesse Jones commissions, but I doubt I will ever go over twenty. I’ve owned a few hundred pipes. It took that many before I figured out what I really liked. I’ve also achieved this level of satisfaction with 6 or 7 tobacco blends.
My dirty secret is that I do not believe in and have never culled. Unsurprisingly, I have also overshot that target.
I have six briar pipes, all different shapes of the Brebbia Ninja Sabbiata line, and a couple of cobs. I find that's plenty for me (almost a week's rotation). I like to keep things simple and I think life is easier with fewer choices, so I decided early on not to amass a big collection of pipes.So I’m wondering who else has achieved complete satisfaction with a collection of 20 or fewer pipes.
I've got somewhere between 200 and 300 boxed up in a storage building. No idea why I ever thought I needed that many. Makes me wish I'd have discovered Falcons decades ago.I have also kept almost everything I’ve gotten, with the exception of pipes I’ve gifted or gotten with the intention of gifting. At this point, the only way I’d qualify for the under twenty pipe limit is that I’m creating seven day sets (albeit, again and again).
@Manawydan I had a Jamestowne clay but it got broken:-(I didn't set out to have a pipe collection per se, but just in the course of experimenting and learning what I liked I ended up with 29 pipes. Realizing there were clearly pipes of those I favored (and several I wasn't smoking) I sent seven off to SP.com for store credit. My current collection of 22 pipes seems like a good number for me. I still want to own a meerschaum and I'd like a Le Dune finish Castello some day but that's about it.
My collection now is in two parts: my Magnificent Seven -- the pipes I smoke regularly, and my Motley Crew -- the oddballs, one-offs, or special pipes that I smoke less frequently.
Magnificent Seven
View attachment 367714
Savinelli Siena 673KS, LCS Briars commissioned bent Rhodesian, Peterson Dublin bulldog, Rattray's Beltane's Fire bent Rhodesian, Vauen Topas smooth paneled apple, LCS Briars bent billiard, and Ashton Pipes Pipe Club of London PotY '25 bent poker.
Motley Crew
View attachment 367715
In reading order: Savinelli 606 alligator blue bent billiard (first pipe I bought), Peterson B42 system spigot, Peterson PotY '24 bent Rhodesian, Parker straight bulldog, Peterson Tavern Rhodesian, Vauen Auenland Eron bent egg, LCS Briars 5-star chrysalis, MM Diplomat cob, MM Jamestowne clay, Falcon Int't stem Plymouth, Falcon Shillelagh twisted blue bulldog bowl, Vauen Jucan #2 smooth brown travel pipe.