Opening A Tin? Show Us!

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Was in the mood for some Jack Knife and after hunting through the jars on the shelves noted i had none currently ready for smoking, soooooo -- off to the cellar i went. This is an 8oz tin dated 10/13 from the factory, which i bought in 12/13 as the labelling suggests. Smells great. Base of golden flue-cured with red va and kentucky, pressed into cakes and finally RR'd. What's not to love? Grabbing a Radice and digging in...

0 3.JPG

O 2.JPG

0 4.JPG
 

Sig

Lifer
Jul 18, 2023
2,062
11,685
54
Western NY
I finally got to opening one of my SG FVF tins from 2008. I have a pound of bulk jarred up, but these tins have been scaring me.
The one I opened is not pretty, it got all jumbled up, but the tobacco is full of sugar crystals and smells great. Im gonna smoke a bowl tonight, jar the rest for the future.....probably tomorrow...then the next day.....
1000007026.jpg
1000007029.jpg
 

Sig

Lifer
Jul 18, 2023
2,062
11,685
54
Western NY
I noticed something weird with this tin of FVF. The top and bottom of the tin were sucked in, that's not weird. When I popped it with my knife, it let out a hiss, and the tin top and bottom popped out a bit. Then I noticed RUST all around the rim of the tin, and starting to go down the sides. THEN I noticed it was NOT rust......its goooo.
It scrapes off with shiny tin underneath. It it sticky and smells strongly of tobacco. Its 100% not rust, I tasted it...its tobacco goo. The tobacco is moist, full of plume, and smells delightful.
This is the oldest rectangular tin I've ever opened, 17 years old.
Has anyone seen this?
The seal was completely intact, and the tobacco is perfect.
Its difficult to get a picture of the goo with my $80 phone camera, but I'll try.
1000007045.jpg
1000007046.jpg
1000007047.jpg
 
Dec 9, 2023
1,905
26,229
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
I finally got to opening one of my SG FVF tins from 2008. I have a pound of bulk jarred up, but these tins have been scaring me.
The one I opened is not pretty, it got all jumbled up, but the tobacco is full of sugar crystals and smells great. Im gonna smoke a bowl tonight, jar the rest for the future.....probably tomorrow...then the next day.....
View attachment 406234
View attachment 406236
Man, I can feeel that moisture.
 

BenMN

Lifer
Jun 21, 2023
3,300
52,597
St. Paul, MN
Well, I'm finally getting around to trying out a Bari Senior pickaxe estate that I picked up a few weeks ago, so I decided I'd better start off with a Danish tobacco. Having none open and available to me tonight, I decided to pop a tin of recently purchased 4th Generation 1931 Flake, and boy oh boy, am I ever glad I did!! It tastes absolutely heavenly and is behaving very well in this pipe!
Much has been said about this tobacco already, so I won't go too deep in my attempt to describe it, but the things that really stand out for me are the lovely sweet and lightly aromatic flavor, the smooth, mouth-filling texture of the smoke, and of course the absolutely wonderful tin note. It smelled so good coming out of the tin that I couldn't wait for it to dry out, and I just lightly pulled it into strips, folded and twisted, and stuffed in into the pipe and lit 'er up!
Fully enjoying this flake and I'm super happy with how the pipe smokes and feels in the mouth and hand. The keystones at the bottom are definitely helping me keep from messing up my mouth as I greedily power though this bowl faster than I ought to on account of my enthusiasm for the whole thing.
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a winning combination!!
View attachment 403926View attachment 403927
Nice X2

Looks like a great flake pipe
 

BenMN

Lifer
Jun 21, 2023
3,300
52,597
St. Paul, MN
I noticed something weird with this tin of FVF. The top and bottom of the tin were sucked in, that's not weird. When I popped it with my knife, it let out a hiss, and the tin top and bottom popped out a bit. Then I noticed RUST all around the rim of the tin, and starting to go down the sides. THEN I noticed it was NOT rust......its goooo.
It scrapes off with shiny tin underneath. It it sticky and smells strongly of tobacco. Its 100% not rust, I tasted it...its tobacco goo. The tobacco is moist, full of plume, and smells delightful.
This is the oldest rectangular tin I've ever opened, 17 years old.
Has anyone seen this?
The seal was completely intact, and the tobacco is perfect.
Its difficult to get a picture of the goo with my $80 phone camera, but I'll try.
View attachment 406243
View attachment 406244
View attachment 406245
I almost wonder if it's degradation of the gasket, interacting with tobacco "fumes"... degrading and absorbing and sort of melting...
 

BenMN

Lifer
Jun 21, 2023
3,300
52,597
St. Paul, MN
View attachment 401930
View attachment 401931
From 2017…sticky residue on inside off the tin. Haven’t seen that before. Inside of tin at ten o’clock in the photo looks like moisture droplets. Very sticky icky.
I have had what I think is similar/same happen with Haddos. The inner layer seemed to have bubbled and degraded. In my case it was more advanced and went all the way through.

I emailed J. Reeves and he said he had never seen such a thing before. I chalked it up to the Haddos, as I know others have had trouble with it long- term in the tin

But maybe it is a tin-wall sealant material defect that rarely happens? I assume that what we see as inner wall is something that is applied to the actual, structural wall

Mine seemed to have bubbled/melted, eaten through, dried, and left crystally-plasticy shards loose around the perimeter inside
 

Mrs. Pickles

Can't Leave
May 8, 2022
381
1,674
AZ, USA
Escudo from 2017. Just opened the tin and in the first third of the first bowl. Last tin I opened was from around 2000 and pretty much not worth smoking. Time will tell how this one goes.

What was off about the year 2000 tin? Flavor too soft from age?

I’ve always wondered about those old painted top AC Petersen tins from that time. They seem to be remembered fondly, but maybe they don’t age well.