I have both the lower and the upper, and I concur. The "lower" two I have are very fine smokers. As are the uppers. The lowers have a bit more wood on them it seems, and they burn a bit cooler because of this. No flies on the budget bunch. The "lower" are more heavily sandblasted, perhaps because their wood isn't as pretty. But it's still briar.If you get the "lower" dot Brigham pipes cheap enough or don't care about the distillator system they are excellent everyday affairs. I found a shop closing that was selling their inventory for about $50US and bought 4 as I have a couple dedicated to specific tobaccos. Couldn't be happier.