Never-Tried Blends in the Cellar?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

LOREN

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 21, 2019
623
1,064
66
Illinois -> Florida
I have three tins of tobacco I
have not tried before. They’re components I like and are ones I’d like to give a try. I think it will be interesting to try them in a couple of years, unless they’re better fresh. But it’s only three tins after all.
 
Dec 11, 2021
1,676
8,696
Fort Collins, CO
Name your king.

Dollar Tree has a basic Memphis rub that does the trick and I'm a fan of the Mccormick line. But I know there are some other legit rubs to up my BBQ game.
Oh man. That’s tough. If I HAVE to pick, I’d take Plowboys BBQ “Yard Bird” for chicken, Killer Hogs “The BBQ Rub” for ribs. Cosmos Q “Dirty Bird” is also damn good. Wait, what’s this thread about….? 😜
I promise I didn’t mean to hijack it!!
 

Architeuthis

Can't Leave
Jan 17, 2021
331
2,322
This very post is predicated on the notion that folks will blind purchase tobaccos they haven't tried. Some do, some don't. Then those who do usually try tobaccos they get, while some may experience circumstances where those tins hit the cellar and events conspire to prevent sampling... I am in this category.

When I first dove in, I found I liked nearly every blend I tried. I read up on reviews at tobaccoreviews and followed Jim's reviews on here. I bought tobaccos that followed my taste profile. I made many orders in this time. Many of my orders included 1-2 oz samples of blends that sounded fun while others gave free sample. The tins I did open went into the tiny jam jars so they didn't dry out. Over the course of about 3 years I ended up with about 60 jam jars full of opened tins/samples of tobacco.

I have never been a prolific smoker. I had a young kid at home, my new wife is awesome but doesn't love any tobacco smell that isn't a deep aro, and I just often had things going on that didn't enable a ton of smoking. In this system, I felt it kind of silly to keep opening new tins until I had finished at least some of the little jam jars.

This did not stop my buying, however. There were $5 tin sales on some pretty amazing blends and I would go, why not? Did I try all of them? No. I was buying at a good time when many people were saying the end of tobacco as we know it was nigh. As a result, I am sitting on more than 300 lb of tobacco and I have not tried quite a few of these blends. When I do, if I don't like them, they will be liked by someone and well aged. I figure they can trade out for stuff I do like at a pretty favorable rate.
I suppose we might draw a distinction between "cellaring" blends you haven't tried vs. simply having a small amount of blends you haven't tried. In my case, when I order something to try, I usually pick up between 1-3 tins or a couple ounces if it is bulk. If it sounds like a style I know I enjoy, I'll pick up 3 tins- 1 to try, 2 to stash. If I like it or it holds promise, I may order more to "cellar". So I have stuff I've ordered to try that I haven't gotten around to trying yet. I think the only blend I "cellared" without first trying was Astley's #44. I know I like this style of Virginia and it tends to disappear very quickly when vendors get a shipment so when I found some I bought a good supply.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scottmi and wyfbane

Servant King

Lifer
Nov 27, 2020
4,815
28,042
39
Frazier Park, CA
www.thechembow.com
Yep, I have several tins in the cellar I haven't tried yet. A couple were bought just on a "hunch," but most of them were just included in lots that I bought on the cheap. Since I have about three dozen jarred blends, I don't plan on digging into any sealed tins anytime soon. My jarred options are sometimes a bit overwhelming--no need to compound that any further!
 

alsatmem

Starting to Get Obsessed
Jan 7, 2019
115
164
Name your king.

Dollar Tree has a basic Memphis rub that does the trick and I'm a fan of the Mccormick line. But I know there are some other legit rubs to up my BBQ game.
324BEA00-C250-4479-B57C-45CF9FBB2406.jpeg
Here is the rub I developed over several years. Savory with a little heat and sweet. I’m a native Memphian for 50 of my 54 years. I prefer Hungarian smoked paprika btw. Also works well with panko or bread crumbs for a homemade shake and bake with chicken or pork chops. Great over fries as well!
 

judcole

Lifer
Sep 14, 2011
7,469
39,056
Detroit
I have zero untried blends in my cellar. Even if I trajectory a flyer on a small batch release, I promptly try it to see if I want to keep it, get more or get rid of it.
I'm pretty much the same way. I'll buy two tins of a new-to-me Virginia - one to smoke now, and one to smoke after aging. I won't buy more unless I like the tin I smoke very soon after purchase.
 

geoffs

Starting to Get Obsessed
Sep 21, 2022
219
824
Ontario
I have a 2-stage cellar. Stage 1 is unopened tins that I haven't tried yet. I don't consider that my cellar so much as tobaccos in waiting. Any one of them can be opened today if it strikes my mood. One of each tin in this group, no more. At my current rate of smoking it might take me another 10 years to get through this stash, but it's growing faster than I'm smoking it.

Stage 2 is what I actually consider my cellar. It's a much smaller collection of maybe 10 blends that I know I really like and will benefit more from aging. I have started to go relatively deep on these (deep for me, but nothing compared to most here). Realistically these are tobaccos I likely won't touch for another 20+ years. As I try new tobaccos if something really strikes my fancy I stock up on it and add a few tins to the long-term cellar.
 

rmbittner

Lifer
Dec 12, 2012
2,759
2,024
Worst case, if I don't like something, I should be able to find a new home for it with another forum member. puffy
That’s not actually the “worst case.”

Worst case is you open a blend you’ve never tried, discover that you love it, find out that it’s no longer being made, and realize you should have picked up more than that one tin… :)
 

rmbittner

Lifer
Dec 12, 2012
2,759
2,024
I have a 2-stage cellar. Stage 1 is unopened tins that I haven't tried yet. I don't consider that my cellar so much as tobaccos in waiting. Any one of them can be opened today if it strikes my mood. One of each tin in this group, no more. At my current rate of smoking it might take me another 10 years to get through this stash, but it's growing faster than I'm smoking it.

Stage 2 is what I actually consider my cellar. It's a much smaller collection of maybe 10 blends that I know I really like and will benefit more from aging. I have started to go relatively deep on these (deep for me, but nothing compared to most here). Realistically these are tobaccos I likely won't touch for another 20+ years. As I try new tobaccos if something really strikes my fancy I stock up on it and add a few tins to the long-term cellar.
I’ve never heard anyone explain a similar approach…and I really like it.

I am now rethinking my entire approach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: geoffs
Jul 26, 2021
2,416
9,811
Metro-Detroit
I have a 2-stage cellar. Stage 1 is unopened tins that I haven't tried yet. I don't consider that my cellar so much as tobaccos in waiting. Any one of them can be opened today if it strikes my mood. One of each tin in this group, no more. At my current rate of smoking it might take me another 10 years to get through this stash, but it's growing faster than I'm smoking it.

Stage 2 is what I actually consider my cellar. It's a much smaller collection of maybe 10 blends that I know I really like and will benefit more from aging. I have started to go relatively deep on these (deep for me, but nothing compared to most here). Realistically these are tobaccos I likely won't touch for another 20+ years. As I try new tobaccos if something really strikes my fancy I stock up on it and add a few tins to the long-term cellar.
I’ve never heard anyone explain a similar approach…and I really like it.

I am now rethinking my entire approach.
I had never really thought of cellaring in these terms, but it is essentially what I have been doing (despite my brain not articulating it).

In short, wide "cellar" to determine likes, which then get truly cellared deep.

Thank you for the perspective.
 
Aug 11, 2022
2,663
20,891
Cedar Rapids, IA
That’s not actually the “worst case.”

Worst case is you open a blend you’ve never tried, discover that you love it, find out that it’s no longer being made, and realize you should have picked up more than that one tin… :)
Touche! There are already a few things I wish I had stocked up on, but I try to be kind to my past self about them. I remember getting bitten every time by McClelland #2015, and Penzance was frustrating because I didn't know how to properly smoke flakes (let alone crumble cakes) at the time. Going forward will be a practice in Buddhist detachment. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Puff nstuff
I can count how many non-aromatic blends that I have tried and have been disgusted by on one hand. I'm not exactly terrified that some of my cellared mystery to me blends will repulse me.
Aromatics are a different story, but I just avoid intentionally aging those in my cellar. I do have some aros, but I only ever buy a few tins of those a year, and open them right away.
 
Aug 11, 2022
2,663
20,891
Cedar Rapids, IA
I have a 2-stage cellar. Stage 1 is unopened tins that I haven't tried yet. I don't consider that my cellar so much as tobaccos in waiting. Any one of them can be opened today if it strikes my mood. One of each tin in this group, no more. At my current rate of smoking it might take me another 10 years to get through this stash, but it's growing faster than I'm smoking it.

Stage 2 is what I actually consider my cellar. It's a much smaller collection of maybe 10 blends that I know I really like and will benefit more from aging. I have started to go relatively deep on these (deep for me, but nothing compared to most here). Realistically these are tobaccos I likely won't touch for another 20+ years. As I try new tobaccos if something really strikes my fancy I stock up on it and add a few tins to the long-term cellar.
Count me as another who digs this philosophy. Along these lines, most of my stash is really Stage 1. But my spreadsheet has "buy more!" next to everything I've tried and liked, with a priority on Virginia blends that might benefit from aging.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Amish Tyrant

SBC

Lifer
Oct 6, 2021
1,638
7,728
NE Wisconsin
I can hardly wait to try anything new that comes in. If I haven't had it before, I'm trying a bowl ASAP, and jarring the rest of that tin.

An exception right now is a tin of Dunhill Dark Flake that I was recently gifted. I have a feeling that I'm going to love it, and I'm enjoying some building anticipation as I wait for more ideal smoking circumstances than I've had lately.

Tomorrow I have the morning off, and it's supposed to get up to 47, so that might just happen...
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThermionicScott

geoffs

Starting to Get Obsessed
Sep 21, 2022
219
824
Ontario
I can count how many non-aromatic blends that I have tried and have been disgusted by on one hand. I'm not exactly terrified that some of my cellared mystery to me blends will repulse me.
I'm with you on this I can pretty much smoke anything without "disgust" but that's too low a bar. Why collect multiples of something that is *meh* when you know there are blends you enjoy more?