I ended up using this review as a way to elucidate my own thoughts on this amazing pipe so please forgive my long-windedness. The short of it is -- this is an amazing pipe.
I finally got my hands on this pipe about a week ago - unfortunately I was working 15 hour days and hadn't the time to give this pipe the review it deserves until today. Don't worry though, none of my initial amazement has worn off.
My first impression upon opening the box was -- wow that's a nice pipe sleeve. I mean, this may be a paltry observation, but this is a really nice leather pipe sleeve. I expected more good things were to come.
The first thing you notice is how beautiful the silhouette of this lovat is. Even with the blast the lines of the shank are dead straight. I swear they taper toward the stem almost imperceptibly to produce a forced perspective - pronouncing the length of the briar shank, the trademark of the lovat shape. Similarly I swear the bowl is canted forward ever-so-slightly, making this 'standard' billiard derivative shape dynamic. The bowl intersects the shank as it should; it neither appears perched on top nor drooping below the shank. The last of the broad scale observations is that the proportions of shank to stem just seam
right. I could deconstruct the proportions (as architects such as myself like to do) and I'm sure I would arrive at a root relationship that appear in all sort of art and biology we find beautiful -- but for now I am happy with the fact that it just looks
right.
The blast on this pipe is just so entertaining. The grain is very tight and the blast is very fine. I find myself turning this pipe over and over in my hands - the ridges of the exposed strata of grain catching the light. There is a lot of variation in the grain which some may find unappealing but that I find delightful. The underside of the pipe is almost like a martian terrain whereas the striations of the 'half moon' grain (as Ryan calls it) really typify what I love about blasted pipes; they really give you a sense of the narrative of this little burl of wood growing, being harvested in to a small block and then shaped in to a pipe.
The horn inlay in the stem is a nice analogue to this natural characteristic I find so interesting in blasts. It has it's own variations in colour and smokey texture that is just a perfect accent. The stem and button are equally amazing and the draw is very smooth. The button demonstrates a continued dedication to detail; the very tip is slightly radiused in plan view and sits comfortably in my mouth.
I am very much looking forward to taking the time to properly break this pipe in and give it its first light. I feel extremely lucky to be in possession of it and the thought of putting flame to it makes me quite nervous! I expect it will smoke beautifully.
You can find more images
HERE
Ok... one more....