We actually have a winner, but I was waiting for him to officially post all 4 in a single post. I guess I can go ahead and declare a winner.
JC knows his stuff!!! Congrats on solving the last two pieces of the puzzle!
#1- McClelland Blackwoods Flake (2013) with nice plume
#2- Esoterica Penzance (2018)
#3- GLP Stonehenge Flake (early 2018) but already has plume
#4- C&D Carolina Red Flake (2018)