I wrote to the excellent customer service people at TopMylar.com and asked about the long-term storage of clear-front vs. opaque bags in an effort to put this to rest once and for all.

Their response:
”Our clear front mylar bags use the same film as our other bags, except the front of the bag does not have the middle aluminum layer so the contents are visible. To maintain a 7 Mil thickness per side, we have an extra layer of clear mylar on the front of the bag. Because the aluminum layer lowers the oxygen transmission rate of the film and the omission of the aluminum would allow light into the bag, these bags are not made for long term food storage. They are typically used in situations when the contents will be consumed within 6-12 months. Our 7 Mil bags without the clear front are intended for long term food storage- up to 30 years depending on the food that is packaged.”
I asked for clarification that even in a dark environment, the clear-front bags would not be suitable for long-term storage. Their response:
”The light safe containers would help with food deterioration due to light (color fading, etc), however it would not help with the oxygen transmission rate. Since this rate is higher without the aluminum layer, oxygen can enter the bag over time. The transmission rate for these bags does not meet the specifications we have to designate a bag capable of long term storage.”
I stand corrected and educated. Hope this helps.