Thank You martiniman....I do appreciate the honer you've given me. But to answer your question... No, I don't think one maker from another affects how the pipe smokes. One looks better than the next because of experience in carving and wax preparation I think. But I'll tell you my opinion on what does matter.... It's the thickness of the bowl. The thicker
the meerschaum bowl is the sweeter and cooler it smokes. The dang thing is, the thicker it is, the slower it colors on it's own. So it's a push and give situation..... I have my favorite carvers and sellers... but I also have some made by beginners that are really great pipes. I carved one myself from a block I got in Turkey and it smokes great. It looks terrible, but, well you know.....
TopD